Cold Case Unsealed
by AC Wilson
The 1985 Doorway Slaying That Fooled a Small Town
About this podcast
Cold Case Unsealed is a gripping true crime podcast that reopens forgotten investigations, unsolved murders, and mysterious disappearances that never received the answers they deserved. Each episode dives deep into cold case files, police reports, witness statements, timelines, and overlooked evidence to uncover the stories buried beneath years of silence. From abandoned leads and vanished suspects to shocking twists and hidden connections, Cold Case Unsealed explores the haunting mysteries that continue to leave families searching for justice. With immersive storytelling, atmospheric narration, and detailed research, the podcast examines the cases that time refused to solve. Some files were closed.
These cases were never finished.
Disclaimer
Cold Case Unsealed is a true crime podcast created for informational, educational, and entertainment purposes. The podcast discusses real criminal cases, investigations, disappearances, and deaths that may include sensitive subject matter. All information presented is based on publicly available sources, news reports, court records, and independent research at the time of recording. Theories and opinions discussed are speculative unless officially confirmed by law enforcement or verified documentation. The podcast does not claim guilt or innocence regarding any individual who has not been convicted in a court of law. Listener discretion is advised due to mature themes, including violence, criminal acts, and disturbing content. This podcast is not affiliated with any law enforcement agency or official investigation.
Episodes
The newest 50 of 337 episodes
- The 1985 Doorway Slaying That Fooled a Small Town · 58 minIn May 1985, Julie McCroy was brutally murdered inside her Andalusia, Alabama, home, launching a decades-long legal battle for her husband, Charles McCroy. Although investigators…
- San Francisco Police Seek Public’s Help to Solve 2010 Cold Case · 31 minThe San Francisco Police Department is currently requesting public assistance to solve the 2010 homicide of Philip DiMartino, a cold case that has remained open for sixteen…
- Arrest Made In 1991 Arlington Murder Cold Case · 30 minThis report details a major breakthrough in a 34-year-old cold case murder from Arlington, Texas, involving the 1991 death of Cynthia Gonzalez. The investigation was revitalized…
- FBI Offers $25,000 Reward To Solve 2 Cold Cases Involving Tribal Citizens In Oklahoma · 37 minThe FBI has launched the Voices Not Forgotten initiative to address the crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Persons by offering standardized $25,000 rewards for information…
- DNA Evidence Solves 2 Austin Cold Cases; Man Sentenced To 15 Years · 29 minThe episode details the conviction of Michael Lance Gamez, who was sentenced to fifteen years in prison for two cold cases involving attempted sexual assault in Austin, Texas…
- Douglas County Sheriff’s Cold Case Awareness Month · 21 minIn observance of National Cold Case Awareness Month, the Douglas County Sheriff’s Office is utilizing social media to spotlight unsolved homicides and generate fresh leads. The…
- Texas Rangers Seek New Tips in 45-Year-Old Salinas Christmas Cold Case · 34 minThe Texas Department of Public Safety is currently seeking fresh leads to resolve the 1980 Christmas Day murders of Estella Salinas and her teenage son, Andrew. Found strangled…
- Fairfax police hope renewed attention will crack 20-year-old cold case · 33 minThe Fairfax County Police Department is seeking public assistance to solve the twenty-year-old cold cases of Marion Marshall and Marion Newman, who were both murdered in 2006…
- Rebecca McMahan Identified in 1974 California Cold Case Murder · 28 minAfter half a century, California law enforcement has successfully identified a cold case murder victim as Rebecca Jean McMahan using modern DNA testing. Her remains were…
- Arraignment in 2001 Farmington Hills Cold Case Murder · 27 minThis news report details the arrest and extradition of Edgardo Luis Perez, who was apprehended in Guatemala after fleeing a 2001 murder charge in Farmington Hills, Michigan…
- The Vanishing of Dorothy Arnold: New York’s Oldest Cold Case · 42 minThe episode examines the mysterious 1910 disappearance of Dorothy Arnold, a prominent New York socialite and aspiring writer. After she vanished during a shopping trip in…
- Utah Man's Disappearance Remains Unsolved 17 Years Later · 18 minThis episode details the unsolved 2009 disappearance of Steven Koecher, a Utah man who vanished after abandoning his vehicle in a Nevada retirement community. Security footage…
- Justice at Last for Terri McCauley · 32 minOver four decades after the 1983 murder of 18-year-old Terri McCauley, a suspect named Thomas Popp is finally standing trial in Sioux City, Iowa. McCauley, a member of the Omaha…
- Identifying Melinda Beardsley: The Emigrant Gap Cold Case Resolved · 32 minIn March 2026, the Placer County Sheriff's Office announced the successful identification of a homicide victim discovered in a snowbank nearly fifty years ago. Previously known…
- Reward Increase for 1996 Juan Laureles Cold Case Tips · 30 minThe Texas Department of Public Safety is currently soliciting public assistance to resolve the 1996 homicide of Juan Leon Laureles in Brown County. The victim was discovered shot…
- The Rachael Runyan Cold Case: Forty-Four Years Unsolved · 31 minThe episode reports on the enduring cold case of Rachael Runyan, a three-year-old girl who was abducted and murdered in Utah over four decades ago. Although her killer remains…
- The Unsolved Murder of Suzanne Jovin: 27 Years Later · 22 minThis episode details the enduring mystery of the Suzanne Jovin murder case, which remains one of Connecticut's most famous unsolved crimes nearly three decades later. In December…
- One Year Later, Emily Pike’s Murder In Arizona Remains Unsolved · 25 minThis episode details the tragic case of Emily Pike, a 14-year-old indigenous girl whose dismembered remains were discovered in a contractor bag along an Arizona highway. Experts…
- Justice Delayed: The Unsolved Murder of C.J. Carroll · 21 minThe episode details the ongoing efforts of an Annapolis family to find resolution a decade after the unsolved shooting of Charles "C.J." Carroll Jr. His relatives and friends…
- Hamden Police Resolve Two Cold Case Homicides · 18 minAuthorities in Hamden, Connecticut, recently announced the arrest of two suspects linked to separate unsolved homicides from several years ago. The first case involves Brian…
- New Lead in 1992 Tammy Zywicki Cold Case Murder · 22 minThis episode reports on a new investigative lead regarding the unsolved 1992 murder of college student Tammy Zywicki, who vanished after her vehicle stalled on an Illinois…
- Solving the 2010 Cold Case Homicide of Philip DiMartino · 23 minThis official news release from the San Francisco Police Department details a plea for public assistance regarding the unsolved 2010 homicide of Philip DiMartino. The victim…
- Hidden in Plain Sight: The Science of Cold Cases · 38 minThis episode examine how modern forensics and persistent investigation can solve long-dormant homicides and assaults. The text details the identification of Doris Mloud, a victim…
- 10 Notorious Pennsylvania Cold Cases · 30 minThis episode highlights ten unresolved homicide investigations across Pennsylvania, spanning from the late 1960s to the recent past. The article explores a variety of mysterious…
- Shattered Dreams: Three Unsolved University Murders · 32 minThe episode recounts the tragic and unresolved murders of three female university students. It begins with the 2007 case of Kelly Nolan, who vanished after a night out in Madison…
- The Huntington Beach Jane Doe · 33 minIn 1968, the discovery of a murdered woman in a Huntington Beach oil field sparked a mystery that remained frozen for over five decades. The victim, initially known only as Jane…
- Metro Nashville Detectives Reopen 1969 Cold Case Involving 12-Year-Old Girl · 24 minLaw enforcement officials in Nashville have officially reopened a cold case involving the 1969 homicide of a twelve-year-old girl. To advance the investigation, authorities…
- The 1977 Tacoma Cold Case of William Church Jr. · 22 minThis episode examines the cold case of William "Bill" Church Jr., a 20-year-old who went missing from Tacoma in 1977. Although skeletal remains were discovered in the decades…
- After 45 years, the Murderer of Krisann Baxter is Identified · 22 minThe episode details the successful resolution of a forty-five-year-old cold case involving the 1978 murder and sexual assault of sixteen-year-old Krisann Baxter in Spokane…
- New Video Released In 2018 Phoenix Cold Case · 26 minThis collection of local reports from an Arizona news outlet covers several significant legal and environmental developments affecting the state. Key stories include the release…
- Texas Rangers Seek Tips in 1997 Brent Gutheinz Murder · 21 minThe Texas Department of Public Safety is requesting the public's assistance to resolve the 1997 cold case murder of Brent Alan Gutheinz, a college student whose body was…
- 81-Year-Old Confesses to German Cold Case Murder of US Tourist in 1994 · 31 minAn 81-year-old man recently confessed to the 1994 murder of a young American tourist, Amy Lopez, during his trial in Koblenz, Germany. The victim was killed more than three…
- Oklahoma’s New Path to Justice for Cold Cases · 24 minGovernor Kevin Stitt recently signed Senate Bill 1636 into law, establishing a structured framework for revisiting cold cases across Oklahoma. This legislative action was…
- Who killed Tupac? What to know about the trial of Duane ‘Keffe D’ Davis · 23 minNearly thirty years after the death of Tupac Shakur, former gang leader Duane “Keffe D” Davis is facing trial for his alleged role in the 1996 Las Vegas homicide. Prosecutors…
- Michigan 1987 Cold Case Solved — Only a Monster Would Do This · 58 minThe episode details the extraordinary resolution of a 35-year-old cold case involving the 1987 murder of Roxanne Wood in Niles, Michigan. For decades, investigators wrongfully…
- New York 1964 Cold Case Solved - A DNA Match Led Police to a Grave · 25 minLaw enforcement officials in Elmira, New York, recently announced the resolution of the 1964 cold case murder of 12-year-old Mary Teresa Simpson. Although the original…
- Colorado 1984 Bennett Family Massacre Cold Case SOLVED · 43 minThis source details the resolution of the 1984 Bennett family massacre, a cold case from Aurora, Colorado, that remained unsolved for nearly four decades. The narrative centers…
- Footprints in the Snow: The Murder of Christopher Green · 47 minThis episode details the brutal 2002 murder of 19-year-old Christopher Green, who was found beaten and stabbed in a rural Michigan ditch. Early investigations considered several…
- Confession Unlocks 1987 Florida Cold Case Murder · 39 minAfter nearly four decades, the 1987 murder of Melissa Ellison in Jacksonville, Florida, has been solved following a voluntary confession by Gary Edward Glowacz. The suspect…
- Detectives Turn To Psychics For Help With Cold Case - CNN Reports · 41 minThis episode details the unsolved 2017 disappearance of fifteen-year-old Sophie Reeder, who vanished after leaving her Florida home late at night. Despite capturing surveillance…
- The Hargan Inheritance: A Legacy of Deception and Death · 50 minThe episode explores the 2017 investigation into the deaths of Pamela and Helen Hargan in their Virginia home. Although authorities initially considered the scene a…
- Man wanted in 2013 Christian County murder captured after 13 years · 23 minThis episode details the successful apprehension of a suspect who spent over a decade as a fugitive. The individual was sought in connection to a violent homicide that occurred…
- Overkill at the Deluxe Plaza Motel · 1 h 10 minThe episode detail the investigations into two separate, violent homicides occurring at roadside lodging facilities. The first case follows the brutal beating of Edward Useda in…
- Chasing Justice in the Cold Case Files - Jeremiah Pittman · 59 minThis episode outlines four decades-old murder investigations that were eventually solved through persistent detective work and modern technology. The first case explores the…
- More Bodies Pulled from Texas Bayou as Serial Killer Fears Ignite · 40 minThe city of Houston is currently grappling with a surge of public anxiety as multiple bodies continue to be discovered in the local bayou system. While widespread social media…
- A Son’s Chance Encounter Reopens His Father’s Murder · 47 minThis episode chronicles the decades-long quest for justice following the 1974 murder of Freddie Farah, a Palestinian-American store owner in Jacksonville. Although the case went…
- Unsolved Crimes and the Science of Justice · 56 minThis episode provides detailed accounts of several cold case homicides that were eventually solved through technological advancements and persistent investigation. In the case of…
- Solving the Barbara Carr - Cold Case Investigation · 39 minThis episode details the 1986 cold case of Barbara Carr, who was brutally murdered in her Garland, Texas, home during a staged home invasion. Initial suspicion fell on her…
- Justice After 26 Years: The Cornell-Story Cold Case Match · 42 minThe episode details the harrowing 1990 double homicide of 11-year-old Robin Cornell and her babysitter, Lisa Story, in Cape Coral, Florida. After the case remained a cold case…
- The Killer Who Thought He'd Never Be Found · 42 minThe episode chronicles the long-delayed resolution of the 1974 abduction and murder of seventeen-year-old Carla Walker in Fort Worth, Texas. For nearly five decades, the case…







