About this podcast
Just two moms hiding in our closets, drinking and talking true crime.
The world is scary, people suck, hide in your closet.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 252 episodes
- The Last One · 2 h 6 min · Season 5 Episode 60The Finale. Always remember... The world is scary, people suck, hide in your closets..... And also.... We LOVE YOU! Beth & Cristy Sources for Menendez Brothers and Casey…
- Grant Solomon and Mark Himebaugh Case Reviews · 1 h 34 min · Season 5 Episode 59Today's episode is special. We are going back and taking a look at two of our controversial cases. We invited our supportive husbands, Wes and Emery, so discuss both of these…
- The Huntington Teenage Murders · 42 min · Season 5 Episode 58In May of 2005, 4 teens were gunned down in the early morning hours by an unknown person or persons. One of the teens, Donte Ward, was connected to a known Detroit drug ring run…
- The Coleman Family Tragedy · 47 min · Season 5 Episode 57The Coleman Family Tragedy revolves around the tragic murders of Sheri Coleman, and her two young sons, Gavin and Garett, in 2009. Chris Coleman was initially considered a loving…
- Sarah Sweeney · 45 min · Season 5 Episode 56Sarah Sweeney was a 39 year old podiatrist living with her fire captain boyfriend in St. Louis, Missouri. In January of 2024 she was found dead in their home from a lethal drug…
- Linda Trinh · 36 min · Season 5 Episode 55Linda Trinh was a 21-year-old student at Johns Hopkins University. She was a bright young lady who had quite the future ahead of her. She wanted to research cures for diseases…
- Kadie Major · 1 h 2 min · Season 5 Episode 54In January 2008, Kadie Major was a 26 year old mom to 10 month old River Lynn and pregnant with a son she planned to name Aidan Robert. On a cold night, Kadie and River went…
- Truman State Suicides · 43 min · Season 5 Episode 53Between 2016-2017, five young lives were tragically lost to suicide at Truman State University and its surrounding community. A chilling connection? All five deaths had ties to…
- Maggie Daniels · 36 min · Season 5 Episode 52Maggie Daniels was a 31 one year old beloved teacher and school counselor in North Carolina. When friends and family didn’t hear from her they immediately sprung into action, and…
- Martin Dillon · 38 min · Season 5 Episode 51In 1976, Martin Dillon, a promising lawyer in Montrose, PA, was shot and killed during a clay shooting trip with his friend, Dr. Stephen Scher. Scher claimed it was an accidental…
- Bernita White · 35 min · Season 5 Episode 50Bernita White was enjoying a local zoo in Lansing, Michigan on a summer day in June 2001. While entering the zoo with her daughter an unknown shooter fired 1 bullet and killed…
- Christopher Gray · 42 min · Season 5 Episode 49Christopher Gray's story highlights the terrible darkness that can sometimes hide beneath small-town familiarity and the ease with which manipulation can turn fatal…
- The Gitchie Manitou Murders · 47 min · Season 5 Episode 48Five teenage friends went out to Gitchie Manitou State Preserve one night in November of 1973 for a fun night of music around a campfire. Sadly, only 1 of them returned home…
- Halloween Collab with WHITW · 1 h 41 min · Season 5 Episode 47Hey Closet Sisters and WHITW fans! We are back with our annual Halloween episode. We are so excited to bring you the 5th installment. Join us as Jess and Cristy tell crazy…
- Sierra LeMar · 34 min · Season 5 Episode 46Sierra was a 16-year-old sophomore in high school. She had just moved and changed schools at the beginning of the year. She quickly became popular and well loved. On March 16…
- Stacey Hanna · 1 h 1 min · Season 5 Episode 43Stacey Hanna was an 18 year old woman who was searching for her place as a member of the LGBTQ+ community. She believed that she had finally found her people in some friends who…
- Stacey Mitchell · 39 min · Season 5 Episode 44Join us as we discuss the murder of Stacey Mitchell. Stacey was a 16-year-old girl who was struggling with getting along with her parents. One day in December she got into an…
- Timothy Ferguson · 47 min · Season 5 Episode 43Timothy Ferguson was a sweet, 15 year old boy, with special needs, living with his mom and 2 brothers. Timothy was found dead in his bed in July of 2022. The findings that came…
- Darren Deon Vann · 51 min · Season 5 Episode 42Darren was an unassuming man walking among us. He had some troubles, including being other than honorably discharged from the military. He had a wife, who would be shocked at the…
- Phillip Ingle · 50 min · Season 5 Episode 40Phillip Ingle had a troubled past and struggled with substance abuse disorder and mental health issues. But then in 1991, he terrorized a small North Carolina town by brutally…








