Criminally Absurd
by Cosy Nasiedlak and Susie Lewis-Peters
Latest episode
46-Kidnapped in Plain Sight: The Story of Virginia Piper
46-Kidnapped in Plain Sight: The Story of Virginia Piper
About this podcast
Criminally Absurd is a comedy podcast that brings awareness to true crime cases with a side of our absurd lives. If you like true crime with some tangents, this may be the perfect podcast for you!
Episodes
The newest 20 of 49 episodes
- 46-Kidnapped in Plain Sight: The Story of Virginia Piper · 57 minEpisode 46- Kidnapped in Plain Sight: The Story of Virginia Piper On July 27, 1972, Virginia Piper, a socialite wife of investment banker Harry “Bobby” Piper, Bobby who was the…
- Episode 45-The Absurd Report: Utah Killings, Children’s bodies in Suitcases, and Prank Gone Wrong · 45 min · Episode 45Episode 45-The Absurd Report: Utah Killings, Children’s bodies in Suitcases, and Prank Gone Wrong This week we are diving into the murders of Margaret Oldroyd, Natalie Graves…
- 44-A Murdered Mother and Missing Baby: The Story of Christine Holloway and Vanessa Morales · 41 min · Episode 44Episode 44: A Murdered Mother and Missing Baby: The Story of Christine Holloway and Vanessa Morales Today we’re discussing the brutal 2019 murder of 43-year-old Christine…
- 43-The Absurd Report: Banfield Case Update, El Mencho Death, Madeline Kingsbury Foundation, and a Huge Break in the Michele Hundley Smith Case · 41 min · Episode 43This week, we are bringing you the latest update in the Banfield double murder case, the falling of El Mencho, the Madeline Kingsbury Foundation information, and the wild resolve…
- 42: Into the Cloud Forest: The Disappearance of Lisanne Froon and Kris Kremers · 55 min · Episode 42Episode 42: Into the Cloud Forest: The Disappearance of Lisanne Froon and Kris Kremers In March 2014, two Dutch college students - Lisanne Froon, 22 and Kris Kremers, 21…
- 41-The Absurd Report: Nancy Guthrie, Morphew Update, James Pearce Jr. Arrest, and Sentencing in the Walshe case · 51 min · Episode 41Introducing our newest segment: The Absurd Report. This week, we’re diving into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, bringing you the latest update in the Morphew case, unpacking…
- 40-The Twin Switch: A Fatal Crash and a Calculated Lie · 51 min · Episode 40Episode 40-The Twin Switch: A Fatal Crash and a Calculated Lie On a September morning in rural Minnesota, four Amish children riding to school in a horse-drawn buggy were struck…
- The Comeback Starts Now: Criminally Absurd Podcast Update · 13 minWe’re officially back—and we’re not doing things the same way this time. Researching, recording, and gearing up for what’s next. Tune in for all the updates 🔥
- 39- Fitbit Murder: Connie Dabate · 1 h 11 min · Episode 39Episode 39- Fitbit Murder: Connie Dabate On December 23rd, 2015, Connie Dabate was found shot to death in her basement. She had two gunshot wounds, one to her stomach and the…
- 38-Concrete Evidence: What Happened to Michael Shaver? · 1 h 9 min · Episode 38Episode 38: Concrete Evidence: What Happened to Michael Shaver? In 2015, Florida husband Michael Shaver vanished without a trace. For more than 2 years, his wife Laurie told…
- 37-The Digital Trail: Dr. Teresa Sievers · 1 h 1 min · Episode 37Episode 37: The Digital Trail: Dr. Teresa Sievers Dr. Teresa Sievers was a beloved holistic physician in Bonita Springs, Florida. In June 2015, she was brutally murdered with a…
- 36-When the System Fails: The Disappearance of Emmanuel Haro · 47 min · Episode 36Episode 36-When the System Fails:The Disappearance of Emmanuel Haro August 14, 2025, Emmanuel Haro, a 7 month old baby boy, was reported missing by his mother, Rebecca Haro, who…
- 35- An Abuse of Power: Justice for Sandra Birchmore · 47 min · Episode 35Episode 35: An Abuse of Power: Justice for Sandra Birchmore Sandra Birchmore was 23 and pregnant, and found dead in her Canton, Massachusetts, apartment on February 1st, 2021…
- Update on Episode 7-Suitcase of Secrets: The Murder of Jorge Torres · 13 minUpdate episode on episode number 7-Suitcase of Secrets: The Murder of Jorge Torres Sara Boon was convicted of killing her boyfriend, Jorge Torres Jr. on October 25, 2024. This…
- Update on Episode 24: The Brom Family Murders · 7 minWe have updates from episode for Episode 24: Family Annihilation: The Brom Family Murders! David Brom, who is a convicted axe murderer, who murdered his mom, dad, and little…
- 34-Ethics in the Eye of the Storm: Memorial Medical Center Story · 57 min · Episode 34Episode 34-Ethics in the Eye of the Storm: Memorial Medical Center Story In the days after Hurricane Katrina, Memorial Medical Center was left without power, running water, or…
- 33-Angelika Graswald AKA the Kayak Killer · 50 minEpisode 33-Angelika Graswald AKA the Kayak Killer On April 19, 2015, Angelika Graswald and her fiancé, Vincent Viafore, went kayaking on the Hudson River near Bannerman Island…
- 32-She Stayed to Help; He Stayed to Murder: The Colleen Ritzer Case · 51 min · Episode 32Episode 32: She Stayed To Help; He Stayed To Murder: The Colleen Ritzer Case In October of 2013, a Massachusetts community was devastated when 24 year old high school teacher…
- 31- Footprints in Blood: The Murder of Jeanie Childs · 39 min · Episode 31Episode 31- Footprints in Blood: The Murder of Jeanie Childs Jeanie Childs, 35 years old, was found murdered in her high rise Minneapolis apartment on June 13th, 1993. At the…
- 30-The Babysitter Who Never Came Home-The Disappearance of Evelyn Hartley · 1 h 15 min · Episode 30Episode 30-The Babysitter Who Never Came Home-The Disappearance of Evelyn Hartley Evelyn Hartley was a 15 year old high school honor student from La Crosse, Wisconsin, who…
