About this podcast
Welcome to Cryptic Soup, an after-dark podcast filled with nightmares that haunt the daylight. Murders, crimes, cons, cryptids, and anything in between. Join the conversation and learn about what might be going bump in the night!
Episodes
The newest 20 of 158 episodes
- The Dyatlov Pass Incident · 2 h 30 min · Season 2 Episode 169Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the well known case of “The Dyatlov Pass Incident”. Nine hikers went out…
- The Watts Family Murder · 1 h 55 min · Season 2 Episode 168Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the sad story of the Watts family. Chris murdered his pregnant wife…
- Joanna Dennehy & the Peterborough Ditch Murders · 1 h 13 min · Season 2 Episode 167Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the life and crimes of Joanna / Joanne Dennehy. This woman was a wild…
- Kai the Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker · 1 h 11 min · Season 2 Episode 166Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss Caleb McGillvary (otherwise known as Kai the Hatchet Wielding…
- The "Mr. Cruel" Case · 1 h 45 min · Season 2 Episode 165Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss one of Australia’s most notorious crimes, still unsolved to the date…
- Nicholas Barclay, the Imposter · 1 h 45 min · Season 2 Episode 164Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about Nicholas Barclay, the 13-year-old child who went missing from San…
- The Angel's Landing Cult · 1 h 16 min · Season 2 Episode 163Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as they discuss Daniel Perez, the mysterious murder of Patricia Hughes, money…
- Tony Carleo aka the "Bellagio Bandit" · 1 h 36 min · Season 2 Episode 162Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as we discuss Anthony "Tony" Carleo, the man who (almost) pulled off one of Las…
- Wendigo · 1 h 20 min · Season 2 Episode 161This might be the funniest episode we've ever recorded... Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as they discuss Wendigos…
- Shani Louk · 1 h 7 min · Season 2 Episode 160Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about the death of Shani Louk. Shani was attending the Nova Music Festival…
- The McCarthy Massacre · 1 h 6 min · Season 2 Episode 159Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee as they discuss the McCarthy Alaska Massacre that occurred one fateful day. It was…
- The Transy Book Heist & American Animals · 1 h 2 min · Season 2 Episode 158Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to discuss the heist of Transylvania University in 2004. Four students created a…
- The Mystery of Cindy James · 2 h 6 min · Season 2 Episode 157Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about the mystery that is the life and death of Cindy James. Cindy and her…
- Brothers Home & the Squid Game Rumors · 1 h 18 min · Season 2 Episode 156Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about Hyungje Bokjiwon (also known as Brothers Home). Brothers Home was an…
- Annaliese Michel · 2 h 4 min · Season 2 Episode 155Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee Kylee to learn about the exorcism of Anna Elisabeth "Anneliese" Michel that took…
- The Life & Death of Liam Payne (Former One Direction Member) · 2 h 19 min · Season 2 Episode 154Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about the rise to fame of boyband, One Direction. We discuss the overworked…
- The Great Clown Panic of 2016 · 1 h 25 min · Season 2 Episode 153Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about the great clown scare that took place in 2016. Some people call it…
- The Wizard of Oz, Oh My! · 1 h 29 min · Season 2 Episode 152Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, (NO SPOILERS WE PROMISE!) join Thena and Kylee to discuss the behind-the-scenes and dark secrets that…
- Janett Christman: "the Call is Coming From Inside the House" · 1 h 26 min · Season 2 Episode 151Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about an urban legend of when a stranger calls. Was the call actually…
- Colton Harris Moore: the Barefoot Bandit · 1 h 14 min · Season 2 Episode 150Welcome to Cryptic Soup, your after-dark podcast. In this week's episode, join Thena and Kylee to talk about a young kid with an appetite for any and all wildness. Colton…








