Show notes
Send us Fan Mail In January 1909, two men entered a small Methodist church in rural St. Clair County, Michigan, and discovered a scene of unimaginable violence. Blood covered the floor, furniture lay overturned, and inside the church stove were the charred remains of a human body. The church's minister, Reverend John Haviland Carmichael, had vanished. At first, authorities believed he was the victim. But as investigators began uncovering evidence, the case took an extraordinary turn. What f...

