Dark Matter Moms
by Dark Matter Moms
Keith Wolf: The Evidence Behind the Cellar Doors
About this podcast
Dark Matter Moms is a true crime podcast hosted by Sam and Sarah, two moms with a passion for uncovering the truth behind real criminal cases. With a special focus on Wisconsin crimes, we dig into court records, trial transcripts, police reports, and investigative documents to tell the stories behind the headlines. From murders and missing persons to courtroom twists and overlooked details, we explore the cases that continue to haunt communities while keeping victims and their families at the heart of every story.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 25 episodes
- Keith Wolf: The Evidence Behind the Cellar Doors · 1 h 0 minOn September 27, 2019, Keith Wolf was shot and killed in the basement of his home in Wisconsin’s Town of Leeds while his wife and daughter were upstairs. Investigators recovered…
- A Deadly Relationship: The Tammy Armstrong Case. · 1 h 11 min · Episode 24In this episode of Dark Matter Moms, we're diving into the disturbing case of Tammy Armstrong, a woman whose relationship with her boyfriend took a dark and deadly turn. What…
- Traci Rataczak – A Sister’s Story | Interview with Tonia Rothweil · 1 h 17 min · Episode 23This week on Dark Matter Moms, we sit down with Tonia Rothweil, sister of Traci Rataczak, for a deeply personal conversation about Traci’s life, her childhood, and what life was…
- Haunted Portage, Wisconsin Part 2 · 32 min · Episode 22This episode, we explore the eerie stories featured in Haunted Portage, Wisconsin by Shelley Mordini and Sharon Hart Addy. From ghostly visitors to spirits lingering in attics…
- Haunted Portage, Wisconsin Part 1 · 33 min · Episode 21This episode, we explore the eerie stories featured in Haunted Portage, Wisconsin by Shelley Mordini and Sharon Hart Addy. From ghostly visitors to spirits lingering in attics…
- The Case of Sagal Hussein: A Son’s Life Lost · 1 h 6 min · Episode 20In this episode of Dark Matter Moms, we examine the disturbing case of Sagal Hussein and the tragic death of her son. We explore the details surrounding the case, the events that…
- Julie Jensen Part 2 · 1 h 24 min · Episode 19Julie Jensen feared for her life—and left behind a letter explaining why. In Part 2, we follow the investigation into her death, the evidence against her husband, Mark Jensen…
- Julie Jensen, Part 1: The Letter She Left Behind · 52 min · Episode 18Before her death in December 1998, Julie Jensen left behind a letter warning police that if anything happened to her, they should suspect her husband. In Part 1, we begin Julie’s…
- Traci Lynn Rataczak: The Question an Acquittal Couldn't Answer · 1 h 30 min · Episode 17NOTICE: IT’S come to our attention the audio in this episode glitches. We’re really sorry about that. We are trying to fix it. On April 8, 2013, 43-year-old mother of three…
- The Murders of Geraldine Knipfer and Michael Walker · 47 min · Episode 15In May of 1992, a brutal double murder rocked the small Wisconsin community of Pardeeville. Geraldine Knipfer and Michael Walker were found murdered inside Geraldine’s home in…
- The Portage House of Horrors, Part 2: I don't want to hurt no more. · 1 h 2 min · Episode 15In Part 2, we return to the house on West Oneida Street in Portage, Wisconsin. We examine the death of Tammi Garlin, the horrific abuse endured by her 11-year-old son, A.C.G…
- The Portage House of Horrors, Part 1: The Boy in the Closet · 1 h 11 min · Episode 14What began as a routine attempt to locate a parentally abducted three-year-old child would expose something far more horrifying inside a home in Portage, Wisconsin. When officers…
- Mary Schlais: The Road to Chicago · 32 min · Episode 13On February 15, 1974, 25-year-old Mary Kathlene Schlais was hitchhiking from Minneapolis to Chicago to attend an art show. She never made it. Mary's body was discovered along a…
- The Fire on Cass Street: The Murder of Daniel Gilmartin · 1 h 35 min · Episode 12On April 20, 2019, firefighters responding to a house fire in Montello, Wisconsin, discovered the burned body of 43-year-old Daniel Gilmartin. Hours before his death, Daniel told…
- The Baraboo Bone Breaker: 43 Hours of Hell · 37 min · Episode 11In the summer of 1995, 13-year-old Thad Phillips went to sleep inside his home in Baraboo, Wisconsin. When he woke up, someone was carrying him away. That someone was 17-year-old…
- Jesse Yanske: A Wisconsin Man Vanishes Without a Trace · 44 min · Episode 10On April 17, 2025, 32-year-old Jesse Yanske disappeared near Westboro, Wisconsin. Despite extensive searches and an ongoing investigation, Jesse has never been found. In this…
- Halloween's Darkest Nightmare: The Lisa Ann French Story · 46 minCAUTION WARNING! This episode contains talk of child sexual abuse. What should of been a night filled with costumes, candy, and childhood excitement became one of Wisconsin's…
- Kevin & Tracy Krueger: A Marriage Ends in Murder · 57 min · Episode 8When first responders arrived at the Ridge Motor Inn in Portage, Wisconsin, they found Tracy Krueger dead outside her motel room. Within 20 minutes, investigators had stopped her…
- Buried Secrets: The Tim and Eve Nance Case · 25 min · Episode 6On the outside, Tim and Eve Nance looked like an ordinary Wisconsin couple trying to build a life together. But behind closed doors, their marriage was unraveling with betrayal…
- Thirty Years Later: The Truth About Curtis Forbes · 59 min · Episode 4On March 11, 1980, 18-year-old Marilyn McIntyre was found brutally murdered inside her Columbus, Wisconsin apartment while her 3-month-old son slept in the next room. Despite…








