Documentary First: Conversations on Documentary Filmmaking
Susan Lacy on Billy Joel, Spielberg and American Masters
· 60 min · Episode 266
Show notes
How did a young woman who had never produced a film build PBS American Masters, and then get Billy Joel to tell the truth on camera?
Susan Lacy created American Masters, the PBS biography series, in 1986, and ran it for nearly 30 years. Then she started over. She founded Pentimento Productions and began directing for HBO: Spielberg, Jane Fonda in Five Acts, Very Ralph and, with her co-director Jessica Levin, the two-part documentary Billy Joel: And So It Goes, which opened the 2025 Tribeca Festival.
In Episode 266, Christian sits down with Susan, who tells it from the start: a college junior reporting on the 1968 Democratic convention in Chicago, where she was hit over the head and nearly thrown into a paddy wagon. A scholar who wrote an article about television and the arts and got a call from Channel 13 asking her to "put your money where your mouth is." A series nobody at PBS thought would work. "I basically willed this series into being," she says. She raised the money herself every year and launched it in the summer, when everyone else was in reruns.
Then the films. Susan did 40 hours of interviews with Steven Spielberg, and his own children told her they'd never heard the stories. With Billy Joel, she started with what they shared: both fathers came to America from Nazi Germany, and her mother was a concert pianist. When she asked him about sensitivities, Billy told her, "Tell the truth." She talks about building the film from his unpublished memoir, cutting three parts to two, and the lunches, dinners and phone calls it took to bring his first wife, Elizabeth Weber, into the film after 40 years of silence.
WATCH THE FILM: Billy Joel: And So It Goes streams on HBO Max.
In this episode, you'll learn:
• What reporting on Chicago in 1968 taught Susan about telling stories under pressure
• How an article about television led to a job at Channel 13
• Why nobody thought American Masters would work, and how she got it on the air
• Why she says passion is "the single most important ingredient"
• How the end of the DVD market changed documentary funding
• Why many American Masters films can no longer be seen
• How a lunch with the head of HBO led to Pentimento Productions
• Why Spielberg asked for his interviews to go in order
• Why she didn't interview Billy Joel chronologically
• How she prepares so she can put her notes away
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
How did Susan Lacy start American Masters?
Susan Lacy says she came up with the idea around 1983, while working at Channel 13 in New York, and nobody at PBS thought it was a good idea. She got a first development grant from the National Endowment for the Arts, kept developing the series while running the Sundance Institute's East Coast office for Robert Redford, and went to markets and festivals in Europe to find partners. American Masters launched in the summer of 1986, when the other networks were in reruns.
How did Susan Lacy get Billy Joel to open up?
She didn't interview him in order. Susan…
Website: documentaryfirst.com
