About this podcast
Jay And Jeff take on the best and worst the holiday horror world has to offer. Watch as two semi-qualified critics slog through endless shlock to finally answer the question, what is the pie for?
Episodes
The newest 20 of 178 episodes
- 2026 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular 5: Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers · 1 h 19 min · Episode 5Send us Fan Mail The Spooktacular comes to an end as Jeff and Jay grapple with yet another Halloween movie, I'm sure it only gets better from here right guys? Guys?
- 2026 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular 4: The Barn · 1 h 21 min · Episode 4Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff head out back to the barn to see what all that 25 year old high schooler racket is! I hope someone doesn't carve out my skull!
- 2026 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular 3: PumpkinHead 4 Blood Feud · 1 h 14 min · Episode 3Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay summon up the spirit of PumpkinHead for a 4th time. Can two star crossed lovers overcome a family feud and a Pumpkinhead? Spoiler: No.
- 2026 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular 2: Jack-O · 1 h 11 min · Episode 2Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay do battle with the pumpkin man/jack-o/an old wizard? Whoever he is he looks badass and my god that shower scene.
- 2026 Horror For The Holidays Halloween Spooktacular 1: Trick Or Treat With Reed Richmond · 1 h 12 min · Episode 1Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay dive into the new spooktacular with an hour of local news level Halloween entertainment! And they love it!
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 90: The Naughty List of Mr. Scrooge (with Collin Murr) · 1 h 22 min · Season 5 Episode 5Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff have a guest and somehow they all ended up on the guest list for a party. I hope we didn't somehow ruin a production of a college play 10-15 years…
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 60: Jeff Rants About The MCU( Heavy Doomsday Spoilers) · 31 min · Episode 60Send us Fan Mail Jeff rants about the MCU and the slap in the face it has been to the fans by essentially saying nothing after Endgame mattered at all!
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 89: Elves(1989) · 1 h 10 min · Season 5 Episode 4Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay didn't have any idea what they were getting into with this one folks! A killer elf! A Nazi incest cult! Grizzly Adams! This is one for the history…
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 59: Overstuffed ANOES Ranking · 27 min · Episode 59Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff dive into the dream world to rank all of the Nightmare On Elm Street movies! Welcome to Primetime Bitch!!!
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 88: XXX-Mas · 1 h 10 min · Season 5 Episode 3Send us Fan Mail Jeff lives out his adult film dreams as Atilla The Hung while Jay tries to review a movie about a killer Santa targeting a Christmas themed porn set.
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 58: Overstuffed Halloween Ranking · 38 min · Episode 58Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay throw out some extra slop for the hogs this week and rank the Halloween franchise!
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 87: Dark Angel · 1 h 8 min · Season 5 Episode 2Send us Fan Mail An alien crosses the galaxy to suck people off in Houston, it's not a joke people! Jeff and Jay were there!
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 57: Golden Chainsaw Awards 2026 · 30 min · Episode 57Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff decide which movies deserve the awards and as the only correct critics on earth this list supersedes the actual results.
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 86: Werewolf Santa · 1 h 16 min · Season 5 Episode 1Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay head back to the jolly old UK to hunt some werewolves! I hope someone in our group isn't secretly a werewolf.......
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 56: Fat Boy Summer Movie Round-up · 29 min · Episode 56Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff talk about Obsession, The Backrooms, and the Scary Movie(2026).
- Horror For The Holidays Episode 85: Uncle Sam · 1 h 23 min · Season 4 Episode 17Send us Fan Mail Jeff and Jay get a crash course in patriotism from their uncle......Sam! Watch as possibly the worst child actor attempts to carry a movie with two female leads…
- Fat Boy Summer Episode 6: Joy Ride 3 Roadkill Unrated · 1 h 6 min · Season 2026 Episode 3Send us Fan Mail The Fat Boys reach the end of line for this summer and in a pleasant surprise the director actually remembered to make a Joy Ride Movie this time! Oh and…
- Fat Boy Summer Episode 5: Joy Ride 2 Dead Ahead Unrated · 1 h 5 min · Season 2026 Episode 2Send us Fan Mail Hey Jay, turns out if your movie is direct to video you can call it unrated, too bad it still sucks. The fat boys are at it again folks and audience........... I…
- Fat Boy Summer Episode 4: Joy Ride · 1 h 7 min · Season 2026 Episode 1Send us Fan Mail The Fat Boys are back and on the road this time. Hey audience, I.....uhhh......I take off your bra.
- Stocking Stuffers Episode 55: Hokum and other nonsense! · 29 min · Episode 55Send us Fan Mail Jay and Jeff talk Hokum and more on this exciting edition of.......Stocking Stuffers!
