It Just Makes Sense
by Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
Latest episode
Chit Chat 225 Isla Had Enough: All These Tacos & Not a Single F*ck…
Chit Chat 225 Isla Had Enough: All These Tacos & Not a Single F*ck…
About this podcast
Welcome to “It Just Makes Sense!” the podcast by two easily distracted higher educated former lovers that explores all of the unpopular opinions, conspiracy theories and cult leaders that make you want to scream “THAT JUST MAKES SENSE!”
Episodes
The newest 50 of 422 episodes
- Chit Chat 225 Isla Had Enough: All These Tacos & Not a Single F*ck Left · 32 min · Season 4 Episode 225Beautiful beaches, brutal golf cart rides, and one very strong “I’m never going back.” This week on Chit Chat, Sam and Jeff are back together, and there’s plenty to catch up on…
- Episode 195: The Murder of Kathy Marlow · 24 min · Season 4 Episode 224A Saturday at the office. A missed lunch date. A devastating discovery. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff cover the murder of 28-year-old finance manager Kathy…
- Chit Chat 223 I'd like to Lodge a FORMAL Complaint! · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 223Free concert tickets, forced workplace fun, and a very firm bedtime. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Jeff hits the Jonas Brothers concert for the suite life and wonders why it…
- Episode 194 The Murder of Mindy Kassotis · 26 min · Season 3 Episode 194A medical emergency. A supposedly dead husband. A third wife who didn’t know his real identity. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff unpack the murder of Mindi…
- Chit Chat 222 Brunch Before Noon? Homophobic. · 36 min · Season 4 Episode 222Halloween parties, wedding merch, and a $35 Taco Bell order. Just another week on It Just Makes Sense, Chit Chat. Sam and Jeff recap their latest adventures, from a party game…
- Episode 193: The Murder of Colleen Slemmer · 30 min · Season 3 Episode 193Jealousy, obsession, and a friendship turned deadly. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff explore the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, a young Job Corps student in…
- Chit Chat 221 Drag Shows, Algorithms, and a Facebook Firestorm · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 221A Facebook firestorm, a social media breakup, and strong opinions about what’s worth watching just another week on Chit Chat with Sam and Jeff. Sam explains why The Social…
- Episode 192 Mommy's Little Sex Dungeon · 25 min · Season 3 Episode 192What looked like a random carjacking unraveled into a chilling family betrayal. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff recap “Mommy’s Little Sex Dungeon” from Mother, May…
- Chit Chat 220 Crime, Housewives & Snack-Fueled Chaos · 33 min · Season 4 Episode 220This week, the girls are CHATTY and absolutely nothing is off-limits. We dive into the latest Gypsy Rose Blanchard drama, debate a shocking, botched execution in Tennessee, and…
- Episode 191 Six Wives, Four Deaths: The Widower and the Thomas Randolph Case · 44 min · Season 3 Episode 191Six wives. Four deaths. One story that just keeps getting stranger. This week on It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff unpack the Thomas Randolph case featured in The Widower: Till…
- Episode 190 The Disappearance of Max Devries · 26 min · Season 3 Episode 190In 2004, 14-year-old Max de Vries vanished during a family trip to Aruba after going jet skiing with a man his family had met at their resort. The man returned. Max didn’t. From…
- Chit Chat 219 Corporate Fraud Alert (It Was Just Blizzards) · 30 min · Season 4 Episode 219Sam worked all weekend staring at spreadsheets, integrations, and corporate nonsense while trying to preserve a single ounce of sanity. Sam said, “That’s cute,” then went to a…
- Chit Chat 218 Fire Hoses, Four Lokos & One Republic · 35 min · Season 4 Episode 218This week with Sam and Jeff, a lunch at Pita Gourmet becomes a full-blown five-alarm emergency, Sam and Jeff recap an unforgettable Bills game complete with free drinks, beer…
- Episode 189 Murder or Freak Accident? The Mysterious Death of Barbara Kendhammer on Country Road · 27 min · Season 3 Episode 189A pipe crashes through a windshield, leaving Barbara Kendhammer fatally injured and her husband, Todd, accused of staging the scene. With conflicting stories, disputed forensic…
- Chit Chat 217: No True Crime, Just Tomahawks, Tailgates & Terrible Decisions · 31 min · Season 4 Episode 217No true crime this week, please direct all complaints to someone who cares. Sam and Jeff are serving up birthday dinners, sponge-candy cheesecake, Bills-induced heart…
- Chit Chat 216: Therapy, Testicles & Thirty-Five Dumplings · 45 min · Season 4 Episode 216Sam and Jeff unpack the humbling chaos of starting a new job, returning to therapy, and redefining a sobriety journey without erasing years of growth. Then it’s pure weekend…
- Episode 188: Hide, Seek, and the Suitcase: The Murder of Jorge Torres · 32 min · Season 3 Episode 188Sam and Jeff examine the death of Jorge Torres Jr. and the case against Sarah Boone, whose claim that a game of hide-and-seek ended in a tragic accident unraveled after…
- Chit Chit 215: Real Housewives, Real Opinions, Real Messy · 38 min · Season 4 Episode 216This week on Chit Chit, Sam and Jeff spiral deliciously through Real Housewives rumors, drag show memories, Buffalo stadium hot takes, taco festival chaos, early-2000s boy band…
- Episode 187 The Murder of Alex Rodda: Social Media, Grooming, and Justice · 26 min · Season 4 Episode 187A 15-year-old boy, Alex Rodda, was found murdered after meeting 18-year-old Matt Mason, a man he had been secretly communicating with online. This episode explores the role of…
- Chit Chat 214: Congratulations on Being Gay · 30 min · Season 4 Episode 215This week on Chit Chat, we’re serving up trial updates, chaotic nights out, questionable dinner plans, steakhouse drama, tiny plates, truffle fry betrayal, and one very iconic…
- Episode 186: The Nolan Wells Case · 30 min · Season 4 Episode 186In episode 186 of It Just Makes Sense, Sam and Jeff dive into the heartbreaking and deeply unsettling case of Nolan Wells, an 18-year-old Mississippi college student whose Fourth…
- Chit Chat 213: Millennials, Trash Pandas & Other Crimes Against Taste · 38 min · Season 4 Episode 214This week, we’re serving chaotic bestie energy with a side of expired millennial dignity. From bland taco bars and office tea that should’ve stayed in the vault, to backyard…
- Episode 185: The Lindsay Clancy Case: Trial, Timeline, and Unanswered Questions · 39 min · Season 3 Episode 185Nancy Grace is back in the biz, WHY NOT US?! So we’re back, and this episode dives into the ongoing Lindsay Clancy trial. A devastating case involving postpartum mental health…
- Chit Chat 212 · 47 min · Season 4 Episode 212
- Chit Chat 211: Ferry Tales, Fairway Fails & Gay Little Chaos · 40 min · Season 4 Episode 211This week, the girls are serving unfiltered chaos with a side of Vermont charm: golf tournament glory-ish, a surprise ferry ride across Lake Champlain, Camp Sam activities gone…
- Chit Chat 210 Scrapbooks, Karens & Calamari: A Gay’s Guide to Surviving the Week · 36 min · Season 4 Episode 210This episode is basically what happens when two gays sit down and unpack a week that should’ve come with a warning label. We start with a scrapbook situation that crosses the…
- Chit Chat 209 20,000 steps a day and still fat · 1 h 3 min · Season 4 Episode 209Jeff returns from his grand European adventure with Copenhagen hot dogs, Amsterdam drag dinners, and a British Open sunburn… but baby, the real turbulence was Miles calling him…
- Chit Chat 208 Medically Fragile Dog, Emotionally Fragile Owner · 34 min · Season 4 Episode 208This episode is basically a leadership seminar, a workplace comedy, and a suburban fever dream all rolled into one. Jeff and Sam kick things off with their signature greeting —…
- Chit Chat 207 Schnitzel Happens: A Barefoot Prayer & A Boat Full of Lies · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 207This week’s episode is a full‑body journey: resurrected dogs, schnitzel scandals, hotel insomnia, THC‑induced game-night paralysis, NHL drafts featuring confused celebrities…
- Chit Chat 206: DILFs, Diapers & Data Centers · 45 min · Season 4 Episode 206This week on Chit Chat, Jeff and Sam return after a whopping 72 hours apart to unpack a weekend filled with bad TV, worse movies, chaotic brunch energy, and enough egg‑roll…
- Chit Chat 205: Abe is RISEN! · 58 min · Season 4 Episode 205
- Chit Chat 204: Lesbian Palooza, Edible Delusions & Summer House Delirium · 44 min · Season 4 Episode 204Two weeks off and somehow we lived nine lives. Sam kicks things off with her annual pilgrimage to Lesbian Palooza, where it rained nonstop, the cabin had the insulation of a…
- Chit Chat 203: Heat Waves, Hot Takes & Home Improvement Hell · 46 min · Season 4 Episode 203Buffalo is melting, Sam is feral about central air, and Cameron is one thermostat decision away from being served papers. Jeff shows up for emotional support, Dairy Queen, and…
- Chit Chat 202 Bloody Marys, Bad Customers & Robot Murder · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 202Get in, we’re oversharing. This week on Chit Chat, we’re serving up everything from chaotic restaurant horror stories (yes, the “we close at 9 but we’ll just stay until 10:30”…
- Chit Chat 201: Devil Wears Prada 2… and We Wear Patience · 47 min · Season 4 Episode 201This week’s episode is a full buffet of chaos, delusion, and questionable taste. Jeff and Sam kick things off by absolutely not agreeing on Devil Wears Prada 2, Sam fell asleep…
- Chit Chat 200 Tarot Cards, Gala Chaos & Grocery Store Drama · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 200Episode 200 is here, and Jeff and Sam show up like two people who absolutely should not have a platform… yet somehow do. Jeff kicks things off by surviving another week of…
- Chit Chat 199: Messy Margaret Stole My Soul · 51 min · Season 4 Episode 199This week’s episode is pure chaos in the best way: Toronto concerts, creepy drag queens, queer emo night, $27 Five Guys meals, and a funeral‑party bar rush all collide before we…
- Chit Chat 198: The Miles Mix‑Up & Other Mental Spirals · 34 min · Season 4 Episode 198Sam and Jeff are back with a week full of unhinged chaos. Sam realizes she’s been texting the wrong “Miles” for two months, Jeff has a full‑body bad high at movie night, and both…
- Chit Chat 197 2000s Worship Nostalgia and Easter Reconciliation · 50 min · Season 4 Episode 197Rarely does one episode pack in a hotel epiphany, a twerking contest, and a Summer House betrayal all in the same breath. This week's conversation covers a genuinely chaotic…
- Chit Chat 196 Coffee at Home and Strip Club Athletics: A Week of Buffalo Adventures · 40 min · Season 4 Episode 196Rarely does a single conversation cover airport runs at 3 a.m., stomach bugs, Easter Markets, and a spontaneous strip club visit, but here we are. This episode is a genuine slice…
- Chit Chat 195 New Headsets and New Management: Jeff's Big Career Move · 43 min · Season 4 Episode 195After a two-week hiatus, Sam and Jeff are back with some big news that's about to shake things up. Jeff just accepted a management position in banking starting April 20th, his…
- Chit Chat 194 Rude Movie Theaters, Hockey Games, and Bakery Mishaps · 41 min · Season 4 Episode 194What happens when you order two half-sheet cakes without knowing their actual size? You'll end up sending guests home with massive amounts of leftovers (which is exactly what…
- Chit Chat 193 Seattle Chaos: Power Outages, Oversized Luggage, and Ferry Rides · 46 min · Season 4 Episode 193Ever wondered what happens when gelato meets a Ferris wheel? Sam and Jeff are back after their Seattle adventure, and honestly, this trip had everything. They nearly missed their…
- Chit Chat 192 Seattle Trip Planning and Weekend Adventures · 54 min · Season 4 Episode 192Sam and Jeff are heading to Seattle and they're buzzing with anticipation. They've been researching Pike Market, debating whether to try clams and oysters, and considering a true…
- Chit Chat 191 Crowdfunding Controversies and Stolen Phones: A Week of Unexpected Lessons · 46 min · Season 4 Episode 191What happens when the people we're supposed to trust break their promises? This week's episode dives into some uncomfortable truths about crowdfunding culture. The conversation…
- Chit Chat 190 Cabo Wedding Chaos and Comedy Club Disasters · 53 min · Season 4 Episode 190Sam and Jeff dive into a wildly entertaining catch‑up session that spans a destination wedding in San José del Cabo, unexpected yacht drama, surprise LGBTQ plot twists, and a…
- Chit Chat 189 A Packed Weekend: Tacos, Drag Shows, and Grammy Takes · 35 min · Season 4 Episode 189A Weekend of Taco Frustrations, Family Birthdays, and Grammy Opinions Why is it so hard to just swap one taco for another? Jeff's weekend started with a frustrating Friday night…
- Chit Chat 188 Seattle Trip Booked, TSA Troubles, and Kidney Stones · 38 min · Season 4 Episode 188After months of procrastination, Jeff finally books their Seattle trip, saving Sam from having to tell everyone it was canceled (again). But the relief is short-lived when they…
- Chit Chat 187 Divorce Drama, Sports Road Trips, and Oscar Debate · 41 min · Season 4 Episode 187What happens when a shattered urinal becomes the secret you take to your grave? Sam and Jeff dive into the week's biggest celebrity drama, starting with Kyle and Amanda's Summer…
- Chit Chat 186 Mercury Tuna, Medical Mix-ups, and Dog-Sitting Drama · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 186Sam's been experiencing headaches, tingling in their extremities, and persistent fatigue. The culprit? Could seven cans of high-mercury albacore tuna weekly for three months…







