About this podcast
Three Mennonite librarians discuss depictions of Amish, Mennonites, and other plain groups in media and popular culture. We review Amish romance novels, other Amish fiction, movies, TV episodes, and more! New episodes most Wednesdays. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter & Instagram @plainwrongpod
Episodes
The newest 20 of 138 episodes
- Wrapping up Season 8: The Heated Rivalry Season · 38 min · Season 8 Episode 18This week is our season 8 wrap up! We chat about season 8, what we'll be up to during our break, provide some media recommendations, and do our seasonal stats round ups, thank…
- Girl Power Bonnet Novel: Discussing Her Heart's Desire · 1 h 1 min · Season 8 Episode 17This week the MennoBrarians discuss the book, Her Heart's Desire by Shelley Shepard Gray. The book follows three young Amish women as they journey to Pinecraft by bus and build…
- Tiny Dinosaurs: A Conversation with Duane Stoltzfus, author of Pacifists in Chains · 57 min · Season 8 Episode 16This week the MennoBrarians chat with Duane Stoltzfus, recently retired Goshen College Professor of Communication, and author of the book Pacifists in Chains. The book tells the…
- Atonement Cheesecake: Discussing the movie Saving Sarah Cain · 53 min · Season 8 Episode 15This week, the MennoBrarians discuss the 2007 made-for-tv movie, Saving Sarah Cain. The movie is about a young journalist (Sarah Cain) who unexpectedly becomes the guardian of…
- Worm in the Guava: A Conversation with Sarah Augustine on the Doctrine of Discovery · 1 h 4 min · Season 8 Episode 14This week the MennoBrarians chat with Sarah Augustine about two of her books, "The Land is Not Empty: Following Jesus in Dismantling the Doctrine of Discovery" and "So We & Our…
- Yer Amish, Harry: Discussing Amish & Mennonite themed Fan Fiction · 1 h 6 min · Season 8 Episode 13This week, the MennoBrarians do a deep dive into the world of fan fiction. The first half of the ep we chat about fan fiction generally - what it is, perceptions of it, and what…
- Mennonites like to gossip: Discussing the movie Amish Stud · 1 h 0 min · Season 8 Episode 12This week, the MennoBrarians discuss the Netflix movie, Amish Stud, a fictionalized story of the murder of Barbara Weaver in Wayne County, OH. Her husband, Eli Weaver, was…
- Bonus episode! Some comments on our Hymn Snake Draft selections · 6 min · Season 8 Episode 11The MennoBrarians first bonus episode?! This short episode is a continuation of our conversation with Bradley Kauffman from the Voices Together hymnal project, in which he…
- Joyful, Illuminating, Nerdy: A Conversation with Bradley Kauffman about Hymns and the Voices Together Hymnal · 1 h 11 min · Season 8 Episode 10This week the MennoBrarians are joined by Bradley Kauffman, who was the project director for the Voices Together Mennonite Hymnal (aka "the purple hymnal") that was published in…
- Alto Part Problems: Drafting our favorite Mennonite hymns · 47 min · Season 8 Episode 9This week, the Mennobrarians chat about favorite Mennonite hymns, including holiday, hymn sing faves, and funeral songs. We always love hearing from listeners! You can reach us…
- Why is there a Maypole? Discussing episodes of Glenn Martin, DDS & 2 Broke Girls · 51 min · Season 8 Episode 8This week, the MennoBrarians watch some TV shows! The first show we review is season 1, ep 2 of Glenn Martin, DDS, a cartoon show about a family traveling the country in a mobile…
- Nostalgic for our own podcast: Celebrating the 125th episode of Just Plain Wrong · 45 min · Season 8 Episode 7This week is our 125th episode of Just Plain Wrong! We celebrate by doing a snake draft of our own podcast episodes selecting 1, the episode we would re-do if we could; 2…
- The Oddball Episode: Chatting about the Podcast Summit, with a dash of Holyman Undercover · 49 min · Season 8 Episode 6This week, the MennoBrarians decide to switch things up and talk about the movie Holyman Undercover for only a small portion of the episode, and instead chat about our recent…
- I will fold your socks for you: A snake draft of our favorite Mennonite traditions · 57 min · Season 8 Episode 5This week, the MennoBrarians snake draft our favorite, most niche, and weirdest Mennonite traditions. We chat MCC Relief Sales, hymn sings, baptism, and how we draw the line at…
- Amish Pemberley: Discussing First Impressions, an Amish Retelling of Pride and Prejudice · 1 h 5 min · Season 8 Episode 4This week the MennoBrarians chat about the Amish romance novel, First Impressions: An Amish Retelling of Pride & Prejudice by Sarah Price. We chat about our favorite P & P…
- Breakfast foods & Recent Faves: Season 8 Intro · 55 min · Season 8 Episode 3This week, the MennoBrarians kick off Season 8! We celebrate the season start with a breakfast foods snake draft, some quick life updates, and chatting about some recent book and…
- Wrapping up 2025: Our Favorite Books and Media of the Year · 59 min · Season 8 Episode 2In this week's episode, the MennoBrarians look back on 2025 and chat about some of our favorite books and media from this past year. Mentioned in this episode: Erin’s 2025…
- A Ladder to Nowhere: Discussing the movie Christmas in Amish Country · 60 min · Season 8 Episode 1The MennoBrarians return for the first of our two holiday episodes, with a recap and discussion on the recently released movie, Christmas in Amish Country. You can find this…
- We need a bigger spreadsheet: Wrapping up Season 7 · 33 min · Season 7 Episode 15In this episode we discuss the highlights of season 7, share some stats and also stories and corrections from our listeners. Highlights include the story of how the More with…
- That's Very 2000 of You: Discussing Plain Truth by Jodi Picoult · 1 h 13 min · Season 7 Episode 14This week the MennoBrarians discuss the selection chosen for us by our Discernment Committee level Patreon members: Plain Truth by Jodi Picoult, published in 2000. This book has…








