Midnight Society Rejects
by Midnight Society Rejects
Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of a Door Unlocked"
About this podcast
Join B.J. and Sarah each week as they toss the midnight dust into the fire and revisit the eerie world of Are You Afraid of the Dark? From Zeebo the Clown’s haunting giggle to the twisted grin of the Ghastly Grinner, they’re deep-diving into every tale that kept us up at night. Whether you’re a ‘90s kid reliving your goosebumps or just B.J. and Sarah’s moms (as always, thanks for your support!), this is your campfire call. (And no, they are not bitter about having their stories rejected by The Midnight Society. Not bitter at all.)
Episodes
The newest 20 of 63 episodes
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of a Door Unlocked" · 36 min · Season 5 Episode 12At long last, the return of Sardo! ("No, Mister, accent on the 'do'!"). Join Sarah and B.J. for a recap about a "little door" (or should we say a pair of little doors) in an…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Vacant Lot" · 54 min · Season 5 Episode 12What's your most valuable possession? And what would it take to part with it? Join Sarah and BJ as they discuss John F. Kennedy commemorative pins, retro chairs, body image, the…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Unexpected Visitor" · 38 min · Season 5 Episode 9What makes a good unexpected visitor? Probably nothing! Join B.J. and Sarah as they reflect on some of their own real-life unexpected guests (ahem, we're looking at you…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Manaha" · 51 min · Season 5 Episode 10Do you love mean counselors? Boys adventuring in the woods? And a level of cultural appropriation that only the 1990s (and everything before and probably after) could provide?…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of Badge" · 45 min · Season 5 Episode 11You know how it is: your little brother wins the science fair, it’s your birthday, your parents make you babysit—and then a sinister spirit awakens, leaving you to clean up the…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of C7" · 41 min · Season 5 Episode 10Sarah and BJ are back to talk lakes, jukeboxes, time warps, and why you should never shame a child for not knowing how to swim. Also: water wings never hurt anyone. Don't touch…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of Prisoners Past" · 40 min · Season 5 Episode 7Sarah and B.J. are back! Again! Because it's Thursday and what else are they doing? This week, they discuss the finer points of Alcatraz escapes, ponder the relationship of…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents "The Tale of Station 109.1" · 47 min · Season 5 Episode 6Radios, hearses, and guest stars—oh my! Join Sarah and BJ for a star-studded and surprisingly deep episode of Midnight Society Rejects as they recap “The Tale of Station 109.1,”…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Mystical Mirror" · 59 min · Season 5 Episode 4When Cindy enters the Elysian Beauty Salon, she gets more than just a makeover… Join BJ and Sarah as they recap “The Tale of the Mystical Mirror.” Along the way, they discuss…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Jagged Sign" · 36 min · Season 5 Episode 2Ever wonder what BJ had on his high school class ring? You’re about to find out... Join Sarah and BJ as they discuss symbols, signs, and why ghosts keep obsessing over unfinished…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Dead Man's Float" · 38 min · Season 5 Episode 1In this episode, Sarah and B.J. ponder the big questions—like how a swimming pool can stay hidden behind a high-school locker. Join them for “The Tale of the Dead Man’s Float,”…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of Train Magic" · 40 min · Season 4 Episode 13All aboard the Midnight Society Rejects Express! Join Sarah and B.J. as they recap a surprisingly great episode featuring dead dads, pocket watches, and history repeating itself…
- Midnight Society Rejects SPECIAL EDITION Episode! · 29 min · Season 1This week, Sarah and B.J. are dropping the recap in favor of diving down the rabbit hole of myths, legends and fun facts surrounding their favorite show! Listen in to learn the…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Unfinished Painting" · 59 min · Season 4 Episode 11What art did Sarah and B.J. hang on their dorm-room walls? What do they think about authenticity, reproductions, and a horsehair paintbrush? Learn about B.J.’s domineering ways…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents "The Tale of the Room for Rent" · 51 min · Season 4 Episode 8Sarah and BJ break down “The Tale of the Room for Rent,” a tale as old as time: about how a pilot killed in combat in World War II returns from beyond the grave to haunt the man…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Fire Ghost" · 42 min · Season 4 Episode 10Join Sarah and B.J. for a fiery new episode filled with hometown lore, haunted fire stations, an unexpected PSA reminding kids that their parents love them, and one important…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Ghastly Grinner" · 49 min · Season 4 Episode 9Sarah and B.J. are back…this time with villains! In one of the most iconic (and blue-goo-covered) episodes of Are You Afraid of the Dark?, middle school odd couple Ethan Wood and…
- The Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Silent Servant" · 1 h 1 min · Season 4 Episode 7Join Sarah and B.J. as they confess their most “illegal” activities—from claw machine heists to the occasional sub-20% tip (allegedly). Along the way, they discuss the things…
- Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Long Ago Locket" · 43 minListen in as Sarah and B.J. dig through the paraphernalia of their past—from Timex watches to hemp necklaces—before recapping “The Tale of the Long Ago Locket.” Featuring Will…
- The Midnight Society Rejects presents, "The Tale of the Water Demons" · 46 min · Season 4 Episode 2Join B.J. and Sarah as they discuss invasions of privacy, reveal the last person Sarah held hands with (seriously—who is Alex?), and explain why you should never, under any…








