Skip to content
Global sound
Moonlight Murders

Moonlight Murders

by Joe

Latest episode
Episode 7: The Aftermath

About this podcast

The Moonlight Murders: Texarkana's Phantom Killer

In the spring of 1946, a masked killer terrorized the twin cities of Texarkana, attacking young couples in lover's lanes under the cover of darkness. Five brutal assaults. Three dead. Two survivors who would never be the same. And a community gripped by fear so intense that hardware stores sold out of locks and guns.

This is the story of the Phantom Killer, one of America's most infamous unsolved cases. Across seven episodes, we'll walk through each attack in chilling detail, follow the desperate investigation that spanned multiple jurisdictions, examine the suspects who could never quite be ruled in or out, and explore how these murders shaped Texarkana forever.

From the first attack on Jimmy Hollis and Mary Jeanne Larey to the murders of Virgil and Katie Starks, from the questionable confession of Youell Swinney to the theories that still swirl today, we're diving deep into a case that inspired The Town That Dreaded Sundown and continues to haunt true crime enthusiasts decades later. The Phantom was never caught.

The case was never solved. But the story deserves to be told.

Episodes

  • Episode 7: The Aftermath · 16 minYouell Swinney was sentenced to life in prison in 1947 for being a habitual car thief. For twenty-six years, he insisted he was innocent of murder. Then in 1973, his conviction…
  • Episode 6: Justice By Any Means · 12 minBy late 1946, prosecutors faced an impossible choice. They believed Youell Swinney was the Phantom Killer. The stolen car pattern was too perfect. Peggy's knowledge of Paul…
  • Episode 5: The Swinney Investigation · 17 minArkansas State Trooper Max Tackett saw what everyone else had missed. Before each murder, a car was stolen. After each attack, that car was abandoned. The Phantom wasn't using…
  • Episode 4: The Farmhouse · 22 minThe Phantom had a pattern. Every three weeks, a young couple on a lovers' lane. Police saturated those roads, waiting for him to strike again. But on May 3rd, 1946, everything…
  • Episode 3: The Youngest Victim · 18 minEaster weekend 1946 brought Texarkana's worst nightmare to life. Fifteen-year-old Betty Jo Booker was a talented saxophonist with the Rhythmaires, playing gigs around town and…
  • Episode 2: Double Murder on Spring Lake Road · 21 minEpisode 2: Double Murder on Spring Lake Road March 24, 1946. A motorist discovers Richard Griffin and Polly Ann Moore shot execution-style in Griffin's Oldsmobile on South…
  • Episode 1: The Town Between Two States · 19 minEpisode 1: The Town Between Two States February 22, 1946. A masked attacker with a white hood and pistol terrorizes a young couple on a secluded Texas lovers' lane. Jimmy Hollis…

Live, last hour: 15,268 songs on 7,093 stations in 145 countries

Discover the world through radio

More ways to discover (9)

Heard something good? Save it, or open it straight away in Spotify.

Radio 538 luisteren - Live!Popular right now