Murder, but Dinner First
by Matt and Rae
Murder Mansion on Cemetery Road: Part Two
About this podcast
Join us as Matt cooks a delicious meal while Rae serves up a chilling true crime story. Between bites, cocktails, and conversation, you'll hear the twists, secrets, motives, and mysteries behind real-life murder cases—all from the comfort of their dinner table.
From infamous crimes to lesser-known cases that deserve attention, Murder, But Dinner First blends dark storytelling with good food, sharp humor, and the kind of dinner conversation your mother probably warned you about.
So grab a plate, pull up a chair, and remember: the murder can wait...
Episodes
The newest 20 of 21 episodes
- Murder Mansion on Cemetery Road: Part Two · 45 min · Season 1 Episode 21We are bringing you a story from Kentucky with even more chaos than last week's episode. There are more unexpected twist, love triangles, jealousy and a wealthy family. Was it…
- Murder Mansion on Cemetery Road: Part One · 57 min · Season 1 Episode 20The dinner is served, the scene is set, and then...chaos. This week's episode did not go according to plan and we are now solving more than one crime. Listen to part one of the…
- The Wichita Massacre · 41 min · Season 1 Episode 19There is no place like home...until it is randomly chosen for one of the worst crimes committed in Kansas. Listen now for a story that will have you double checking that you…
- The Villisca Axe Murders · 1 h 18 min · Season 1 Episode 18When an axe murderer hits a small town in Iowa, the town all rushes to the scene. This unsolved case might just have you believing in ghost. Are they leading you to the killer?…
- Bonus Episode: Prom Night Killings · 1 h 0 min · Season 1 Episode 17As promised after the teaser in this week's earlier episode, here is the story of the Pelley Family Murders. A paster uproots his family to a small town in Indiana before a…
- Murder, Bombs, and Burgers: The Speedway Cases · 1 h 8 min · Season 1 Episode 1This story will have you on the fast track to looking more into the crimes that occurred in Speedway, Indiana in 1978. Detectives turned right when they should have been going…
- The Demise of Bruce Lindahl · 1 h 2 min · Season 1 Episode 15This story leads starts with murder and ends with an unexpected twist. Is is karma? Or maybe just fate? Listen now to hear the story of Bruce Lindahl and the ending not even he…
- The Blackfoot Murder · 1 h 14 min · Season 1 Episode 14Idaho may be known for it's potatoes, but they are not the only thing in hot water. We are back from our trip and right back to work. Listen to this episode to learn more about…
- The Honolulu Hostage Crisis · 58 min · Season 1 Episode 13What happens when an ex-employee with some built up rage wants revenge? Join us to find out and you won't believe the twist at the end.
- The Alday Family Murders · 1 h 12 min · Season 1 Episode 12While the peach cobbler may be delicious, these murders are a little suspicious. Learn what happened to the Alday Family in this weeks tragic story. Don't forget to make yourself…
- The Black Widow of Florida · 60 min · Season 1 Episode 11It's not all sunshine and beaches in Florida. Judy Buenoano not only had dark secrets hidden in her medicine cabinet, but something in the trunk of her car as well.
- Serial Killer Keith Gibson · 1 h 2 min · Season 1 Episode 10Keith Gibson killed multiple people in two states, but what if he could have been stopped before more innocent lives were lost? Listen now to hear the story. But don't forget…
- The Lynching of Charles Lockwood · 50 min · Season 1 Episode 9This weeks dinner is filling and not at all suspicious like our dear friend Charles Lockwood. Join us for delicious dinner from Connecticut and story that will have you…
- The Weightlifting Killer · 50 min · Season 1 Episode 8This murderer can bench press more weight then the amount of crimes he committed...maybe. Listen now to hear the story of Marvin Gayle Gray and his criminal career. But first…
- Bonus Episode: Ladles Belong in the Kitchen · 1 h 2 min · Season 1 Episode 7Rae shares how to not get murdered while traveling and the best weapon of defense, then tells you a murder bedtime story that will have you checking to make sure your door is…
- The Neighbor from Hell · 48 min · Season 1 Episode 6A couple in California buys their dream home and starts their life with their family, but the neighbor has other plans.
- Bonus Episode: Devil's Den Double Homicide · 21 min · Season 1 Episode 5Can't sleep? Neither can we. Here is one more bedtime murder story before you tuck yourself in. Don't forget to lock the door.
- The Phantom Killer · 1 h 14 min · Season 1 Episode 4This unsolved killing spree will keep you up at night wondering if the Phantom Killer is still up in the night looking for his next victim. Listeners lock your doors and join us…
- The Remorseless Murderer · 40 min · Season 1 Episode 3Join us for dinner inspired by Arizona. Then sit back and listen to a murder case that will leave you hungry and filled with questions we may never get the answers to. Good thing…
- The Butcher Baker · 54 min · Season 1 Episode 2Tonight's dinner (and murder) is brought to you by Alaska. Pull up a chair and join us at the table to hear about The Butcher Baker.








