About this podcast
Maggie and Heidi discuss a different true crime case in each episode.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 23 episodes
- The Allenstown 4 · 45 min · Season 2 Episode 4It started with the discovery of a barrel in the woods, and then, years later, another one. Inside were the remains of a woman and three young girls. In this episode, we talk…
- The Disappearance of Andrew Gosden · 41 min · Season 2 Episode 3In 2007, Andrew Gosden, a 14-year-old, went missing from King's Cross Station without any prior indication of an intention to leave his home. Since that time, there have been…
- Gay Gibson: The Porthole Murder · 51 min · Season 2 Episode 2In 1947, 21-year-old stage actress Gay Gibson disappeared while voyaging from South Africa to England. The story from her accused killer would even get the attention of Winston…
- Selena · 2 h 4 min · Season 2 Episode 1Selena Quintanilla-Pérez was a Tejano singer who captured hearts and rose to fame in the late 80s and early 90s. She was a true fashion icon, adored by fans in Texas and Mexico…
- Season 1 Finale: Spooky Special · 40 min · Season 1 Episode 15Yes, we're late but... Surprise! It's the Season 1 Finale! It's Summertime and in Florida, that means Tourist Season. Between that and some personal things, Maggie and Janessa…
- Richard Trenton Chase: The Vampire of Sacramento · 31 min · Season 1 Episode 14Richard Trenton Chase was living under the delusion that his blood was turning to powder. Unfortunately, instead of receiving the mental health assistance he desperately needed…
- Nai Yin Xue: Martial Arts Master · 38 min · Season 1 Episode 13After a 3-year-old girl was found abandoned in a Melbourne, Australia train station, the ensuing investigation led to a worldwide manhunt for her parents - and the discovery of a…
- Jane Toppan: Jolly Jane · 48 min · Season 1 Episode 12We've moved to Wednesdays! Jane Toppan had a difficult childhood which she overcame to become a nurse. She was so friendly and well-liked by patients and staff that she earned…
- Abigail Williams & Liberty German: Last Seen on Snapchat · 50 min · Season 1 Episode 11Abby Williams and Libby Germain were 14-year-old best friends who were spending the day taking pictures on the Monon High Bridge. The last time anyone heard from them was when…
- Edward Wayne Edwards: Reformed Conman Turned Murderer · 40 min · Season 1 Episode 10Edward Wayne Edwards was proud to be the shining example of a reformed prisoner, having gone from the FBI's Ten Most Wanted List to paroled motivational speaker. It wasn't until…
- John Haigh: The Acid Bath Murderer · 1 h 4 min · Season 1 Episode 9John Haigh's life was one of petty crime, though it had the trappings of wealth. The secret of where he got his money, however, was hidden down drains and in his workshop's back…
- Robert Hansen: The Butcher Baker · 53 min · Season 1 Episode 8Robert Hansen was a baker and champion hunter who lived in Anchorage, Alaska. He seemed to have outrun his troubled past, until local sex workers began turning up dead in the…
- Bonus: Interview with Maggie's Parents · 20 min · Season 1Janessa has Covid-19, so instead of a normal episode, today we bring you an interview the Murder Moms did with Maggie's parents about the time in 1987 that her dad came home from…
- Mary Bateman: The Yorkshire Witch · 41 min · Season 1 Episode 7Mary Bateman was a witch and prophetess in the 1800s. She and her cohorts, Mrs. Moore and Miss Blythe, used their magic to care for the people of Leeds. All was going well…
- Westley Allan Dodd: The Devil Dodd · 54 min · Season 1 Episode 6"Westley Dodd was a predator who fell through the cracks of an inefficient, overburdened legal system, graduating from relatively harmless acts of exhibitionism to the depths of…
- Xavier Dupont de Ligonnès: Secret Spy Part 2 · 58 min · Season 1 Episode 5Xavier Dupont de Ligonnès seemed to have it all: a loving wife, four happy children, two dogs, and an aristocratic title. But he had secrets, and one day he walked away from all…
- Xavier Dupont de Ligonnès: Secret Spy Part 1 · 45 min · Season 1 Episode 5Xavier Dupont de Ligonnès seemed to have it all: a loving wife, four happy children, two dogs, and an aristocratic title. But he had secrets, and one day he walked away from all…
- Special Edition: Thoughts Regarding the Failed Coup Attempt · 1 h 6 min · Season 1Janessa and Maggie spend some time working through our thoughts and feelings about the failed coup on January 6, 2021. Although our podcast has an explicit rating, we would like…
- Dorothea Puente: Death House Lady · 35 min · Season 1 Episode 4Dorothea Puente was a landlady whose tenants were disenfranchised and had addictions. Instead of encouraging them and helping them to get back on their feet, Dorthea specialized…
- Frank Walls: A Personal Connection · 43 min · Season 1 Episode 3Maggie's dad came home from work one day in 1987 to find that his neighbors had been murdered. Janessa and Maggie dive into the case, and take listeners on a short road trip…








