Notions of Progress
by Marshall Madow
Liberalism and the Social Question: Helena Rosenblatt on Guizot…
About this podcast
The idea of progress — that humanity advances through time toward something better — has been a contested assumption throughout history. The question of whether we as a species, a nation, or as individuals are progressing is being interrogated with a renewed urgency that the present moment demands. Whether that advancement is real, illusory, unevenly distributed, or simply beside the point depends on who is asking, from where, and by what measure. Notions of Progress is a podcast that takes those questions seriously, tracing how the idea of progress has been understood, contested, and reimagined from antiquity to the age of artificial intelligence.
The series moves from the ancient Greeks’ ambivalence about technological change, through the Enlightenment’s confidence in cumulative human reason, to the contemporary moment in which artificial intelligence has made the question of progress newly urgent. When machines appear to learn, create, and reason, the assumptions buried inside the word “progress” — about agency, direction, and human advancement — are no longer abstract. Tracing how those assumptions formed, and how they have been challenged across centuries, is the work of this podcast. Rather than prescribing a position, it surfaces the debates — examining how thinkers from Hesiod to Hayek, from Plato to Peter Haff, have understood what it means for humanity to move forward, at what cost, for whom, and by whose definition. The thread connecting Plato’s Academy to the age of artificial intelligence is not a straight line of accumulation — it is a recurring argument about whether progress is something driven by human agency, providence, or an artificial consciousness we project onto history rather than find in it.
Host Marshall Madow brings an unusual dual formation to these questions. His MA in History from Cambridge University — where his thesis examined Georges Sorel’s epistemology of myth and the role of ideas in animating collective action — gave him a grounding in how belief systems about progress can function in place of rational thinking as historical forces. His MSc from Oxford University’s Saïd Business School, specializing in Complexity Science and Leadership, introduced him to the question from the other direction: how systems evolve, how change propagates through institutions, and why linear models of advancement are often insufficient in explaining complex phenomena. The two areas of study point toward the same problem from opposite ends. Notions of Progress is the inquiry that connects them.
Marshall approaches the podcast as a scholar, researcher, and curator — seeking to surface a pluralistic and wide-ranging spectrum of ideas rather than prescribing or advocating one position over another.
Contact: [email protected]
Social: @notionsofprogress on Instagram · @NotionsProgress on X/Twitter
Web: notionsofprogress.com
Episodes
The newest 20 of 24 episodes
- Liberalism and the Social Question: Helena Rosenblatt on Guizot, Marx, and Napoleon III · 30 min · Season 1 Episode 24In this second part of a three-part conversation, historian Helena Rosenblatt follows the liberals of nineteenth-century France into the social question, drawing on her 2018 book…
- From Liberal to Liberalism: Helena Rosenblatt on the History of a Word · 38 min · Season 1 Episode 23In this first part of a three-part conversation, historian Helena Rosenblatt traces the history of the words “liberal” and “liberalism,” the subject of her 2018 book The Lost…
- Is Capitalism Past Its Use-By Date? Michael Roberts on Three Futures About This Episode · 13 min · Season 1 Episode 22In this third and final part of the conversation, Marxist economist Michael Roberts brings the argument of his 2016 book The Long Depression into the present. He begins with the…
- Two Depressions, One Cause? Michael Roberts on 1873, 1929, and the Rate of Profit · 15 min · Season 1 Episode 21In this second of a three-part conversation, Marxist economist Michael Roberts takes the central claim from Part One — that the 2008 crash opened a long depression — back to the…
- A Marxist in the City of London: Michael Roberts on The Long Depression · 30 min · Season 1 Episode 20In this first of a three-part conversation, Marxist economist Michael Roberts joins Notions of Progress to lay out the central argument of his 2016 book The Long Depression: that…
- Nothing About This Is Inevitable: Gavin Mueller on Automation, AI, and a Different Future · 13 min · Season 1 Episode 19This episode closes out a three-part conversation with Gavin Mueller (University of Amsterdam), author of Breaking Things at Work. In Part 2, Mueller traced Marx's own…
- Theorizing the Machine: Gavin Mueller on Marxism, Taylorism, and Cybernetics Interview pt 2 of 3 · 24 min · Season 1 Episode 18In Episode 17, Gavin Mueller (University of Amsterdam) traced the Luddites back to the guild economy of England's Midlands. In this second installment of a three-part…
- Breaking Things at Work: Gavin Mueller on the Luddites and Labor Resistance pt 1 of 3 · 35 min · Season 1 Episode 17They've been remembered as machine-smashers who tried to stop the future with a hammer — but historian Eric Hobsbawm called what they were doing “collective bargaining by riot.”…
- After Alexander: Diogenes, the Cynics, and a City With No Walls · 10 min · Season 1What happens to an ethics built on belonging to a city once that city stops being able to protect anyone? This episode opens the Hellenistic arc of Notions of Progress by tracing…
- Aristotle on Human Nature — Blueprint vs. Destiny · 16 min · Season 1 Episode 15Aristotle claimed that human beings have a built-in purpose — but is that idea a foundation for a good life, or a blueprint for control? This episode, the second half of a…
- Aristotle, Telos, and the Good Life: What Human Flourishing Actually Means pt. 1 · 11 min · Season 1 Episode 14In the last three episodes, Matt Ehret argued that the history of progress is a contest between two competing visions of civilization: one that develops its internal capacities…
- Interview with Matt Ehret Pt. 3: Plato vs. Aristotle: The Divide That Still Shapes How We Think · 11 min · Season 1 Episode 13What if the divide between Plato and Aristotle is not a chapter in the history of philosophy — but a structural fault line that still determines how civilizations think about…
- Interview with Matt Ehret Pt. 2: The Allegory of the Cave · 31 min · Season 1What if the most cited passage in Western philosophy has been deliberately misread — by both its critics and its supposed followers? In Part 2 of his conversation with Matt…
- Interview with Matt Ehret - Plato vs. Aristotle: The Flame, the Vessel, and the Fate of Human Progress · 38 min · Season 1 Episode 11Matt Ehret argues that the divide between Plato and Aristotle is not a historical curiosity confined to the ancient world — it is a living fault line that continues to shape how…
- Aristotle vs. Plato: Two Theories of Progress — and the Institution That Produced Both · 19 min · Episode 10The Academy was built on a wager: that philosophy could be institutionalized, accumulated, and transmitted across generations. Episode 10 asks whether the bet paid off — and…
- How Did Plato’s Academy Teach What Could Not Be Taught? · 29 min · Season 1 Episode 9Plato named philosophy. But naming it was only the first move. The harder question was whether an institution could be built to make the progress he was wagering on actually…
- The Word and the Wager: How Plato Named and Claimed Philosophy | Ep. 8 pt 1 · 17 min · Season 1 Episode 8About This Episode Where did the word “philosopher” come from — and who got to decide what it meant? In Episode 8, Part 1 of Notions of Progress, we trace the moment Plato took…
- Plato vs. the Sophists: Rhetoric, Power, and the Making of Callicles | Ep. 7 pt 2 · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 7About This Episode Can rhetoric make better citizens — or does it simply make better manipulators through the art of persuasion? In Part 2 of the Plato vs. the Sophists arc…
- Plato vs. the Sophists: The Allegory of the Cave As His Answer On Progress | Ep. 6 pt 1 · 21 min · Season 1 Episode 6In this episode of Notions of Progress — the first of a two-part examination of Plato — we ask what happens to the Sophists’ theory of progress once Plato is done with it. The…
- The Sophists: Fifth Century Enlightenment? | Ep. 5 Pt.1 · 22 min · Season 1 Episode 5About This Episode In this episode of Notions of Progress — the first of a two-part solo series — we ask a deceptively simple question: were the ancient Greek Sophists the…








