Only Murders on the Harbor
by Kaydee Mittleider
The Grayland Murder: Kenneth Hutchison
About this podcast
Only Murders on the Harbor takes you deep into the misty corners of Grays Harbor County, Washington, where rugged coastlines, towering forests, and small-town charm conceal a darker side. Known for its eerie landscapes and quiet, coastal towns, this region is also home to some of the Pacific Northwest's most chilling true crime stories. In each episode, we explore haunting tales of serial killers, unsolved disappearances, and strange, unexplained events that have left a lasting mark on the community. From eerie forests to forgotten backroads, the county’s history is ripe with mystery and menace.
With thorough research, gripping storytelling, and interviews with experts, we dive into the crimes and unsolved cases that have shaped Grays Harbor's dark legacy. Whether it’s chilling accounts of justice served or lingering mysteries that still haunt the area, Only Murders on the Harbor unveils the chilling truth behind the most terrifying cases that have made this region a haunting backdrop for crime and intrigue. If you’re ready to uncover the secrets buried in the fog, this podcast is for you.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 27 episodes
- The Grayland Murder: Kenneth Hutchison · 14 min · Season 2 Episode 6n the quiet coastal community of Grayland, Washington, a man suddenly disappeared, and the explanation that followed raised more questions than answers. In August 2008…
- Lost to Water · 9 min · Season 2 Episode 5Tonight on Only Murders on the Harbor, we examine two haunting Grays Harbor cases connected by water, isolation, and unanswered timelines. In January 2023, 53-year-old Gerald…
- Disappearance on Madison Street: Tyler Jennings Inman · 11 min · Season 2 Episode 4In this episode of Only Murders on the Harbor, we revisit a decades-old missing persons case from coastal Washington that unfolded during a powerful winter storm. A routine…
- The Log Roller of Grays Harbor: William "Billy" Charlie · 12 min · Season 2 Episode 3In the early 1900s, the rivers of Grays Harbor were more than just waterways—they were the center of work, community, and survival. Among those who lived and worked on the water…
- The Deputy in the Road - Carlton Mason Stearns · 23 min · Season 2 Episode 2In this episode of Only Murders on the Harbor, we explore the mysterious death of Deputy Sheriff Carlton Mason Stearns, a cold case that has puzzled Grays Harbor County for…
- The Road That Remembers - David Allen Gerard · 25 min · Season 2 Episode 1Season Two of Only Murders on the Harbor opens with one of the most disturbing cases to emerge from Grays Harbor County, Washington. This episode examines the life and violence…
- William "Billy" Gohl - Part 2: The Ghoul of Grays Harbor — Trial, Secrets, and the Final Reckoning · 44 min · Season 1 Episode 20Between 1905 and 1910, Aberdeen, Washington’s harbor became a place where men vanished and bodies surfaced with unsettling regularity. Newspapers called them “floaters.” Locals…
- The Ghoul of Grays Harbor Part 1 — Rise and Dark Waters of Billy Gohl · 25 min · Season 1 Episode 19Step into the fog of early-1900s Aberdeen, Washington—a boomtown of mills, muddy streets, and a harbor crowded with sailors from every corner of the world. In this episode of…
- The Man Sentenced to Die Three Times but Lived: The Guido Grassi Murders - Part 2 · 29 min · Season 1 Episode 18We follow the case from the night of the murders through multiple trials, appeals, insanity hearings, political battles, and a series of last-minute legal maneuvers that…
- The Night of Blood & Fog: The Guido Grassi Murders - Part 1 · 23 min · Season 1 Episode 17In this episode, Kaydee investigates a chilling case from Grays Harbor County, Washington, in November 1923. A string of brutal murders left a predominantly Italian immigrant…
- The Burning Question: The Murder of Marlon Lee · 11 min · Season 1 Episode 16On the night of November 18, 2008, Marlon Lee, a 41-year-old resident of Aberdeen, Washington, was brutally beaten and set on fire after leaving the Quinault Beach Resort &…
- Murder on the Gravel Bar: The Killing of Jimmy Smith-Kramer at Donkey Creek · 22 min · Season 1 Episode 15This episode of Only Murders on the Harbor examines the death of 20-year-old Jimmy Smith-Kramer, a Quinault tribal member whose life was tragically cut short in a racially…
- The Catfish Con: The Murder of Curtis Engeland · 27 min · Season 1 Episode 14In this episode of Only Murders on the Harbor, Kaydee unravels the tragic story of Curtis Engeland, a 74-year-old retired professor from Mercer Island, Washington. Known for his…
- Under the Chehalis River Bridge · 20 min · Season 1 Episode 13On April 8, 2000, sixteen-year-old Daryn C. Tolle left a Friday night “Rock & Bowl” dance in Aberdeen, Washington. A harmless tradition among friends turned tragic when he walked…
- Echoes of Justice - The Murder of Albert Hakkarainen · 20 min · Season 1 Episode 12In this episode, we take a deep dive into a dark night in Aberdeen, Washington—October 17, 1953—that forever changed the lives of its residents. We recount the tragic murder of…
- May Day Martyr - The Murder of William McKay · 24 min · Season 1 Episode 11In this episode of Only Murders on the Harbor, host Kaydee explores the 1923 murder of William McKay, a dedicated Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) organizer in Aberdeen…
- Ashes and Embers - The Fire that Changed Aberdeen · 28 min · Season 1 Episode 10In this haunting and powerful episode, host Kaydee takes listeners to October 16, 1903, when the booming timber town of Aberdeen, Washington, was nearly reduced to ashes by one…
- The Marshal of Cosmopolis · 18 min · Season 1 Episode 9In November 1901, a routine civil warrant in the Pacific Northwest turned deadly. In the boomtown of Cosmopolis, Washington—where timber mills ran nonstop and the law walked on…
- The Death of Dan Damitio - Felony, Firearms, and a Fatal Error · 24 min · Season 1 Episode 8On the night of February 2, 1963, three individuals — Reinhart Nelson, John Patrick Jr., and Alberta “Dolly” Burns — drove through a rainy Grays Harbor night with one goal: to…
- The Bassett Murders — Retrial and Release - Part 2 · 20 min · Season 1 Episode 7In this episode, host Kaydee continues the story of Brian Bassett, who at age 16 committed the tragic murders of his parents, Michael and Wendy Bassett, and his 5-year-old…








