Sobre este podcast
Every week Florida's appellate courts hand down decisions that change how your next case goes, and most of them slip by while you're in court. Reasonably Safir catches them.
Host Rory Safir is a Florida criminal defense and injury trial lawyer, and one of only six attorneys in the state designated a Forensic Lawyer-Scientist by the American Chemical Society's Chemistry and the Law Division. Each week he walks the newest rulings from the Florida Supreme Court and all six District Courts of Appeal, calls out the wins you can put to work in a pending file that same week, and flags the losses that could reach your open cases and reshape your theory.
No ivory tower. Plain language, real doctrine, and takeaways you can carry into your next hearing, whether you're fighting a search or proving a claim.
Built for criminal defense lawyers, plaintiffs attorneys, and anyone whose job is representing a real person against an institution. The caselaw roundup lands every Friday. Science deep dives and stories from the road land in between, whenever there's one worth your time.
Safir Injury and Criminal Defense Law welcomes referrals and co-counsel arrangements from fellow attorneys.
Episodios
- First Things First: Florida Caselaw, Week of November 13, 2026 · 27 min · Episodio 18Florida caselaw for the week of November 13, 2026: the Florida Supreme Court receding from State v. Williams on speedy trial recapture, an inventory search after a reckless…
- Speedy Trial, Separate Criminal Episodes and Bicycle Stops: Watch the Conduct (Florida Caselaw, Nov. 6, 2026) · 27 min · Episodio 17Florida caselaw for the week of November 6, 2026: a speedy trial discharge reversed because two drugs found in one car were two criminal episodes, a frisk during a bicycle-light…
- Melbourne Jury Strike Reversed: Prove It on the Record (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 30, 2026) · 19 min · Episodio 16Seven criminal decisions and two injury decisions: a peremptory strike reversed under Melbourne, the knowledge element in driving while suspended, a third-DUI plea and a…
- Wrongful Incarceration Claims and Punitive Damages Deadlines: Say It on Time (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 23, 2026) · 18 min · Episodio 15Eight criminal decisions and three injury and insurance decisions: a former death row defendant’s wrongful incarceration petition sent back, a confession through an uncertified…
- Constructive Possession in a Trafficking Case: Whose Is It (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 16, 2026) · 25 min · Episodio 14Nine criminal decisions, a civil procedure decision and a rule change: a key to a safe that wasn’t possession, a downward departure reversed, a discovery violation the prosecutor…
- Crash Reconstruction Without an Expert in Vehicular Homicide: The Side Door (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 9, 2026) · 27 min · Episodio 13Six criminal decisions, three injury decisions and a rule change: two vehicular homicide convictions reversed over a detective’s speed formula, polygraph-prompted admissions, the…
- Resisting Without Violence and a Stop With No Basis: The Missing Element (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 2, 2026) · 27 min · Episodio 12Eight criminal decisions, two civil decisions and two rule changes: a resisting conviction thrown out over a bare 911 description, a hot-car felony murder reversed for lack of…
- Excluded Defense Evidence and Medical Examiner Hearsay: What the Jury Hears (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 25, 2026) · 27 min · Episodio 11Ten criminal decisions and three injury decisions: a Sarasota sexual battery conviction reversed over one word the jury never heard, PTSD evidence after Oquendo, the First and…
- Proving a Probation Violation and a Life Care Plan: Show Your Work (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 18, 2026) · 25 min · Episodio 10Florida caselaw for the week of September 18, 2026: Sarasota curfew proof, a Manatee bond hearing, a DUI stop, postconviction claims, stalking, and future medical expenses. Smith…
- Welfare Check or Seizure in a Sleeping Driver DUI: The Second Question (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 11, 2026) · 27 min · Episodio 9Eleven criminal decisions and one injury decision: the Second District reversed suppression in a Hillsborough sleeping-driver DUI because nobody had spoken to him yet, a murder…
- DUI Blood Draw Suppression Affirmed in State v. Marlin: The Shortcut Week (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 4, 2026) · 23 min · Episodio 8All criminal this week: the Fourth District affirmed suppression of a forced blood draw on the State's own appeal and receded from the sentence prosecutors had been citing for a…
- Erlinger and the Prison Releasee Reoffender Statute: The Wrong Door Week (Florida Caselaw, Aug. 28, 2026) · 20 min · Episodio 7Four criminal and two injury-side decisions where nobody lost on the merits, plus a deep dive on the footnote where the State conceded the PRR statute is unconstitutional, and…
- Double Jeopardy and Blockburger in Florida: The Counting Week (Florida Caselaw, Aug. 21, 2026) · 20 min · Episodio 6All criminal again this week: one act the State counted as two, a juvenile review clock set ten years late, and a deep dive on how Florida decides when one crime becomes several.
- HGN in Florida DUI Cases, Part 3: Three Days in a Classroom · 21 min · Episodio 5What is actually inside the course that qualifies officers to give this test. I sat through it twice.
- Missing Charging Documents and Good Faith Warrants: The Paperwork Week (Florida Caselaw, Aug. 14, 2026) · 15 min · Episodio 4All criminal this week: a conviction with no charge behind it, a revocation built half on hearsay, two warrant fights decided the same day, and a deep dive on the good faith…
- HGN in Florida DUI Cases, Part 2: Eighty Eight Percent, or Thirty Seven · 13 min · Episodio 3One figure in one study produces both numbers. Which one gets said in court depends on who is talking.
- HGN in Florida DUI Cases, Part 1: The Eyes · 16 min · Episodio 2The strangest piece of evidence in a Florida DUI case, and the only one nobody can review. Part one: what nystagmus actually is, the three clues, the sixteen-second floor, and…
- The One Who Checks: Cross-Examining an Officer on HGN and a Lazy Eye · 15 min · Episodio 1How a one way ticket to the Outback ended with a cop on the stand who couldn't define a lazy eye.








