About this podcast
Welcome to Seasoned Skeptics — the horror podcast where a total newbie gets thrown into the deep end of scares, guided (and occasionally roasted) by a no-filter horror veteran.
Hosted by Nick (the wide-eyed horror rookie who's barely scratched the surface of movies, let alone the blood-soaked world of slashers, supernatural terrors, and creature features) and Derral (the seasoned expert with decades of deep dives, hot takes, and zero patience for bad tropes or lazy jump scares).
Together, we break down the latest and greatest (and weirdest) in horror: from fresh releases and underrated gems to classics that still hold up — plus in-depth recaps of must-watch series like HBO's IT: Welcome to Derry (we're basically your #1 obsessive source for all things Pennywise and Derry drama).
Expect unfiltered reviews, plot-hole probing, skeptical side-eye at overrated hits, celebration of gloriously trashy B-movies, and plenty of "wait, what just happened?" moments.
We can't help but veer wildly off-topic — whether it's debating golf etiquette, unpacking wild pop-culture conspiracies, geeking out over comics, or riffing on whatever random tangent sparks mid-scream.
It's chaotic, honest, hilarious, and always real — no scripted fluff, just two friends arguing, laughing, and geeking out over what makes horror tick.
If you're a horror die-hard looking for fresh perspectives, a newbie wanting to dip your toes in without going in blind, or just love podcasts that feel like hanging out with friends who won't shut up about scary movies... hit play. We've got the scares covered — so you don't have to face them alone.Subscribe now for weekly(ish) episodes packed with screams, skepticism, and zero apologies. New here? Start with our creature features, revenge thrillers, or the latest IT: Welcome to Derry breakdowns — trust us, you'll be hooked.What are you waiting for? Turn down the lights, crank the volume, and join the skepticism.
Episodes
- Skeptic vs. the Absurd: Hollywood Chainsaw Hookers (1988), Oily Maniac (1976) and Tourist Trap · 57 min · Season 1 Episode 13Seasoned Skeptic goes full exploitation mode this week with a triple bill of retro weirdness. From the blood-soaked, chainsaw-swinging cult in Hollywood Chainsaw Hookers to the…
- Horror Movie Reviews: Becky (2020), Wrath of Becky (2023), and Sinister (2012) · 1 h 14 min · Season 1 Episode 12Seasoned Skeptics is back with a vengeance-themed triple bill! We tackle the Becky saga: the original 2020 film where a rebellious teen turns the tables on invading convicts…
- Horror Movie Reviews Smile 2 (2024) Black Phone 2 (2024) and Vicious (2025) Dakota Fanning's Character. · 45 min · Season 1 Episode 11The latest episode of the Seasoned Skeptics Podcast is out now, and we're diving deep into some of the freshest (and freakiest) horror releases while keeping our signature…
- Horror Movie Reviews: Smile (2022) Black Phone (2021) and Gremlins (1984) · 45 min · Season 1 Episode 10Join hosts Nick and Derral on Seasoned Skeptics as the horror genre rookie (Nick) gets schooled by long-time fan Derral in this chilling yet fun breakdown! We dive deep into…
- Horror Movie Reviews: Companion (2025), Together (2025), and The Monkey (2025) · 42 min · Season 1 Episode 9Join hosts Nick and Derral on Season Skeptics as we dive into three wild 2025 horror releases we binged this week! We break down: The Monkey (Osgood Perkins' Stephen King…
- Horror Movie Reviews: Christmas Episode: Terrifier 2 (2022) and 3 (2024), and The Mean One (2022) · 44 min · Season 1 Episode 8Dive into the chills with Nick and Derral's festive fright, On Seasoned Skeptics, where horror takes flight! This holiday episode's a bloody delight, Reviewing slashers that…
- Breaking Down IT: Welcome to Derry Finale "Winter Fire" · 33 min · Season 1 Episode 7Join hosts Nick and Derral on the Seasoned Skeptics Podcast as we dive deep into the explosive season finale of HBO's IT: Welcome to Derry – Episode 8, "Winter Fire"! In this…
- Horror Movie Reviews: Troll, Troll 2, and Frankenstein 2025 · 40 min · Season 1 Episode 6Seasoned Skeptic Podcast: Reviewing Netflix's Troll (2022), Troll 2 (2025), and Guillermo del Toro's Frankenstein (2025)! Join hosts Nick and Derral on this epic monster mash…
- Periwinkle Burnt Down the Blackspot? Welcome to Derry Episode 7 Review · 25 min · Season 1 Episode 5Welcome to Derry – Episode 7: “The Black Spot” – Episode Summary Episode 7 is a gut-wrenching, lore-heavy penultimate chapter that many fans are calling the strongest of the…
- Pennywise is the Father? IT Welcome to Derry Episode 6 Recap · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 4Season Skeptics is your irreverent guide to dissecting TV and film seasons through the sharp lens of skepticism, hosted by the dynamic duo Nick and Derral. Each episode, they…
- Horror Nerds Movie Reviews: Bring Her Back, Weapons, and The Shining. · 36 min · Season 1 Episode 3Nick and Derral tear into THREE wild films with zero mercy: WEAPONS (2025) – The controversial new horror-comedy from Zach Cregger (Barbarian) starring Josh Brolin and a truly…
- IT "29 Neibolt Street," Welcome to Derry Cranks Up · 26 min · Season 1 Episode 2In "29 Neibolt Street," Welcome to Derry cranks up the terror as Pennywise the Dancing Clown finally struts into full view, courtesy of Bill Skarsgård's chilling return. The…
- IT: Welcome To Derry Review · 36 min · Season 1 Episode 1In this conversation, Nick and Derral delve into the first four episodes of the series set in Derry, exploring character dynamics, plot developments, and the overarching themes…








