Shades of Murder
by Alita Cauldwell
83: The First Scream Murder - The Killing of Gina Castillo
About this podcast
Shades of Murder is a true crime podcast dedicated to in-depth research and deep, thoughtful analysis of the world's most chilling and disturbing cases. Hosted and created by Alita Cauldwell, each episode meticulously explores the murders and motivations of violent criminals and delves deep into how law, culture, and society intersect. Episodes include serial killers, children who kill, female criminals, teenage killers, historical murders, indigenous cases, cold cases, marginalized victims, and dark, haunting mysteries. Criminology-based. No banter. Never sensationalized.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 84 episodes
- 83: The First Scream Murder - The Killing of Gina Castillo · 43 min · Episode 83Before Cassie Jo Stoddart...there was Gina Castillo. In 1998, in a suburb of Los Angeles, two teens committed a crime that became a real-life horror copycat. Sealed behind a…
- 82: The Death Machine of Texas - The Curse of Johnny Frank Garrett · 52 min · Episode 82As a terrified, disabled young man pleads for mercy for a crime he swore he didn’t commit, the State of Texas remains hell-bent on carrying out an execution dressed up in legal…
- 81: Good vs. Evil in Amarillo - The Halloween Murder of Sister Tadea Benz · 57 min · Episode 81On Devil's Night in Amarillo, Texas, one of society’s most vulnerable would become a target of a sadistic predator. The investigation into their shocking death would ignite rage…
- 80: Death Row Women - The Trials and Aftermath of Teenage Killer Christa Pike (part 2) · 55 min · Episode 80Only seven days to go until Tennessee’s planned execution of Christa Gail Pike takes place on September 30th, 2026. Part 2 of this deep dive into her case extends far beyond the…
- 79: Terror in Tennessee - The True Story of Colleen Slemmer and Christa Pike (part 1) · 40 min · Episode 79On September 30th, 2026, Tennessee is expected to execute its only woman on death row, Christa Gail Pike. This gripping two-part special of Shades of Murder is pulled straight…
- 78: The Monsters of Ecatepec - Mexico's Serial Killer Couple · 1 h 4 min · Episode 78When police placed a seemingly ordinary couple under active surveillance on October 4, 2018, they were hoping to discover a link to the wave of disappearances plaguing Ecatepec…
- 77: Twisted Twins - Jasmiyah and Tasmiyah Whitehead of Georgia · 48 min · Episode 77On January 13, 2010, in Conyers, Georgia, a 16-year-old girl frantically waved down a passing patrol car. She and her twin sister had just returned from school to discover a…
- 76: Bodies in the Garden - The Dupont de Ligonnes Family Mystery · 1 h 31 min · Episode 76In April 2011, an unimaginable act of horror shook the beautiful, peaceful town of Nantes, France. Investigators discovered a pattern of disturbing behavior and alarming…
- 75 - Death at Sunset Cliffs - The Mystery of Michelle Von Emster · 57 minIn mid-April, late afternoon, amidst the dimming sunlight over the Pacific Ocean, the body of a woman was discovered, and it was missing the right leg. What initially appeared to…
- 74: The Dinner Party Murder - An Invitation to Death · 1 h 18 min · Episode 74When a group of friends comes together for a lovely autumn meal, a casual gathering escalates to murder. The events that culminated in the death of an innocent person revealed a…
- 73: Death at the Mayor's House - Jennifer Kirk and Susanna "Sue Sue" Norton, AK · 1 h 12 min · Episode 73In early March 2020, in a small town in Northern Alaska, the body of a young woman was discovered on the Mayor's property, and she wasn't the first. An investigation would expose…
- 72: Buried in the Backyard - The Diabolical Web of Kwaneta Harris · 52 min · Episode 72In the Fall of 2007, when a VA Agent contacted the Garland, Texas, police department about a suspicious-looking piece of concrete on a property, what lay beneath it would unfold…
- 71: The Dismemberment Trials of Sweden - The Coroner and The General Practitioner · 1 h 23 min · Episode 71Within a few weeks of one another near Stockholm, Sweden, suspicious-looking trash bags were found discarded on a motorway. Homicide detectives were stunned and horrified by what…
- 70: True Horror Indonesia - The Mystery of Vina and Eky · 54 min · Episode 70In the summer of 2016, the bodies of two teenagers were discovered along a bridge in the port city of Cirebon. What first appeared to be a tragic motorbike accident would unfold…
- 69: Making of a Monster - The Shoe Fetish Slayer part 3 · 1 h 29 min · Episode 69What makes a monster? How does a small child one day innocently discover a pair of women’s high heels and turn into one of the most sadistic and depraved serial killers in…
- 68 : Evidence of Evil - The Shoe Fetish Slayer part 2 · 1 h 2 min · Episode 68The investigators and crime scene analysts who searched the workshop and home of serial killer Jerome “Jerry” Brudos were shocked and horrified by the evidence of evil that lay…
- 67: Hunt for a Serial Killer - The Shoe Fetish Slayer part 1 · 1 h 23 min · Episode 67Along the Long Tom River in Oregon, the body of a missing young woman was discovered. Her disappearance and murder were a string of mysterious incidents in the region. Detectives…
- 66: Evil in Ontario - The Abduction of Tori Stafford · 1 h 16 min · Episode 66When two depraved, twisted minds crossed one another’s paths, they would embark on a plan of true evil. Their cruel, sick desires would lead to one of the most horrific crimes in…
- 65: Did She or Didn't She? - The Mysterious Case of Noura Jackson · 1 h 24 min · Episode 65On June 5th, 2005, in Memphis, Tennessee, a woman discovered in a blood-spattered bedroom would lead homicide investigators to the most rare of suspects. This case would unfold…
- 64: Christmas Witchcraft Murder - Kristy Bamu, London, UK · 50 min · Episode 64On Christmas Day, 2010, in London, UK, first responders arrived at a couple’s blood-spattered flat. The discovery of a young man’s tortured body would uncover a disturbing and…








