Shall We Brew
by Hayley
The Disappearance of Relisha Rudd: How an 8-Year-Old Vanished from a…
About this podcast
Shall We Brew? is a true crime podcast hosted by Hayley. Each episode serves up freshly brewed tales of chilling crimes, shocking scams, and scandalous secrets. From betrayals that cut deep to cons so bizarre they feel unreal, Shall We Brew? takes you through the twisted and unexpected. So pour yourself a cup and settle in… because once we start brewing, the truth can’t be unsipped. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 22 episodes
- The Disappearance of Relisha Rudd: How an 8-Year-Old Vanished from a D.C. Shelter · 35 minIn March 2014, 8-year-old Relisha Rudd vanished while living with her family at a homeless shelter in Washington, D.C. What began as a routine school attendance concern quickly…
- Pt 2: The Vienna Woods Killer · 1 h 2 minIn part two of The Vienna Woods Killer, we follow how investigators finally zeroed in on Jack Unterweger—a celebrated writer and “rehabilitated” ex-con who was secretly hunting…
- Pt. 1: The Vienna Woods Killer · 40 minPart 1 explores the early victims, crime scenes, and unexplained murders stretching from Austria to Los Angeles. We break down where the bodies were found, how the women were…
- A Lawyer, A Client, & Triple Homicide · 28 minTiffany Eichor was trying to rebuild her life after leaving an abusive relationship, moving back home with her parents in Beggs, Oklahoma for support and safety. But one night…
- The Ghostface Mask & A Serial Killer’s Halloween Secret · 32 minIn a haunting episode of "Shall We Brew?", the stories of Jennifer Still and the Greaves family—Heather, Lisa, and young Avery—are woven together by the obsession of John…
- 0 Truths, All Lies, and a Snapchat Trail · 40 minWhen 23-year-old Chandler Halderson told everyone he was graduating from Madison College and heading to SpaceX, his parents believed him. Then Bart and Krista Halderson…
- The Murder Hidden Behind a Custody Battle · 29 minShe was a young mother fighting for custody — and for her life. When 24-year-old Alyssa Burkett pulled into work that October morning, she didn’t know she was being watched…
- New Husband Mysteriously Vanishes on Honeymoon · 31 minA dream honeymoon in the Mediterranean turned into a nightmare at sea. In July 2005, 26-year-old newlywed George Smith vanished from the Royal Caribbean cruise ship Brilliance of…
- Cold Case Solved: Beloved Teacher Found Dead & Handcuffed in Bath Tub · 34 min · Episode 14In this episode we uncover the chilling case of Mary Catherine Edwards—a vibrant and beloved teacher from Texas. For over 20 years, her murder remained unsolved. Decades later, a…
- What Happened During the New Orleans New Year’s Attack · 31 min · Episode 13On New Year's in New Orleans, a celebration turned to chaos when a violent attack shocked the city. In this episode, we dive into the details of the horrifying events, exploring…
- Toxic Yoga Twins Drive Off Cliff After Ripping Out Sister’s Hair · 38 min · Episode 12A picturesque drive on Maui’s treacherous Hana Highway turned deadly for twin sisters Anastasia and Alexandria Duval in May 2016. Known for their volatile relationship and dark…
- Mother & Daughter Murder with a Root Beer Float · 20 min · Episode 11A loving husband and stepfather, Harold Allen Jr., trusted his family with his life—but what he didn’t know was that his wife and stepdaughter were plotting his death. In this…
- American YouTuber Abducted by Fake Cops in the Philippines · 22 min · Episode 10Elliot Eastman, an American vlogger, lived in Sibuco, the "red zone" in the Philippines, documenting his life in a region marked by beauty and danger. On October 17, 2024, he was…
- The Deep Fry Killer: Man Cooks Wife in Kitchen · 16 min · Episode 9In Jackson, MI - what led a local chef to commit a crime so horrifying it shook an entire community? In this episode of Shall We Brew?, we delve into the chilling story of the…
- Heir to $290 Million Fortune Murders Best Friend on Christmas Eve · 11 min · Episode 8This episode of Shall We Brew? covers the tragic & alleged killing of 23 year old William Bush, on Christmas Eve 2023. His longtime friend, Dylan Thomas—an heir to a $291 million…
- Into the Shakahola Forest: Uncovering Kenya’s Cult Massacre · 39 min · Episode 7Dive deep into the chilling story of the Shakahola Forest Massacre, where hundreds of people fell victim to a deadly cult led by self-proclaimed pastor Paul Mackenzie. In this…
- Unmasking Bob Lambert: Undercover Agent That Impregnates Woman, Disappears, & Sets Fire to Store · 41 min · Episode 6What happens when a cop takes undercover work too far? In this episode, we expose the story of Robert “Bob” Lambert, an officer who created a false identity to infiltrate…
- Cartel Catfished: How a Fake Drug Ring Conspiracy Led to Murder · 22 min · Episode 5In this episode of Shall We Brew?, we dive into the shocking case of Nathaniel Huey Jr., a man who was catfished by his own fiancée into believing he was under surveillance by…
- A Hex, A Duplex, & Mysterious Deaths: The Story of Carolann Smith & The Hex House · 29 min · Episode 4Step into the shadowy world of Carolann Smith, the mysterious woman at the center of one of Tulsa’s most chilling true crime stories. Known as the "Hex House," Smith's unassuming…
- The Nurse, The Flame, and The Lethal Dose · 18 minIn the spring of 2018, Centerville was left in shock when a devastating house fire revealed the lifeless body of local musician Tim Pasa. What first appeared to be a tragic…








