Saltar al contenido
Global sound
Short Circuit

Short Circuit

Short Circuit 447 | How Constitutional Are Your Claims?

· 46 min

Notas del episodio

We focus on a district court case that has appellate court explanatory power. As our special guest Professor Robert Steinbuch says, if you reside in Arkansas you must be living in a cave if you haven’t heard of the Malinowski matter. The lawsuit concerns the tragic death of a man who was shot by the police in a raid after he shot first. His widow alleges the man did not know the people breaking into their house were police as they did not properly announce themselves. Because the police were ATF members, or task force members who were working with the ATF, the ability of the widow to sue for damages is limited. For constitutional claims that means a Bivens claim. For non-constitution (or are they non-constitutional?) claims that means the Federal Tort Claims Act. The court threw out the first route but kept most of the second. Professor Steinbuch and IJ’s Anya Bidwell explain what the court said, what was right and what was questionable, and who these issues mean for the larger debate, including efforts in state legislatures to provide alternatives to Bivens.

Malinowski v. U.S. (FTCA claims)

Malinowski v. U.S. (Bivens claims)

Docket for Nielsen v. Watanabe

Professor Steinbuch’s column on Malinowski case

Bound By Oath episode on Bivens claims

Web: ij.org

En directo, última hora: 12.405 canciones en 6.058 emisoras de 142 países

Descubre el mundo a través de la radio

Más formas de descubrir (7)

¿Has oído algo bueno? Guárdalo o ábrelo directamente en Spotify.

★ Artista de la semana El que más sube en la radio esta semana
¿Tu canción aquí? Desde € 9 por semana →
WNBIMPS RadioSeguir escuchando