Sinners Among Saints
by Megan and Lindsay
Episode 199: The Nightmare Before Halloween: The Murder of Rebekah Gay
About this podcast
Hey Sinners! It's us, Megan Keyes and Lindsay Martinez.
Welcome to "Sinners Among Saints," the chilling true crime podcast that delves deep into the dark underbelly of society. Created by two best friends hailing from Utah, who share a passion for all things horror, this podcast aims to shed light on the victims of heinous crimes that often go unnoticed.
Join us as we navigate through the twisted tales of real-life monsters and the innocent souls they prey on. With meticulous research, compelling storytelling, and a lighthearted feeling of chasing with friends, "Sinners Among Saints" takes you on an immersive journey into the darkest corners of humanity. From unsolved mysteries to well-known cases, we explore the sinister motives, mind-bending twists, and relentless pursuit of justice.
Thank you so for your continued support. We love you all!
You can contact us at: www.sinnersamongsaintspodcast.com [email protected]
https://www.instagram.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast/
https://www.facebook.com/people/Sinners-Among-Saints-Podcast/100086073002378/
On Twitter @SASpodcast_22
If you would like to offer further support please visit our Patreon at: https://www.patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
AND REMEMBER TO KEEP LISTENING IF YOU WANT IN ON THE SIN!
RSSVERIFY
Episodes
The newest 20 of 206 episodes
- Episode 199: The Nightmare Before Halloween: The Murder of Rebekah Gay · 1 h 7 min · Season 1 Episode 199Send us Fan Mail On Halloween 2012, 24-year-old Rebekah Gay, a young mother from Michigan, was brutally murdered in her own home while her three-year-old son was nearby. The man…
- Episode 198: The Fox Hollow Haunting · 1 h 13 minSend us Fan Mail Deep in the woods of Indiana sits Fox Hollow Farm, a property with a horrifying history that goes far beyond your typical ghost story. Once home to serial killer…
- *RECYCLED EPISODE* Episode 122: Christa Pike // The Youngest Woman Sentenced to Death · 1 h 25 minSend us Fan Mail Before we get into today’s episode, we wanted to take a moment to explain why we’re bringing this particular case back to you. We originally covered the case of…
- Episode 197: Herb Baumeister and The Fox Hollow Murders // Part 2 · 1 h 11 minSend us Fan Mail On this week's episode of Sinners Among Saints, Lindsay and Megan dive into the chilling story of Herb Baumeister — a man who was never arrested, never…
- Episode 196: Herb Baumeister and The Fox Hollow Murders // Part 1 · 1 h 21 minSend us Fan Mail On this week's episode of Sinners Among Saints, Lindsay and Megan dive into the chilling story of Herb Baumeister — a man who was never arrested, never…
- Episode 195: Friends Like These: The Betrayal of Skylar Neese · 1 h 16 min · Season 1 Episode 195Send us Fan Mail On the night of July 5, 2012, 16-year-old honor student Skylar Neese slipped out of her bedroom window in Star City, West Virginia, climbed into a waiting sedan…
- Episode 194: Madeline Soto: Behind Closed Doors · 1 h 48 min · Season 1 Episode 194Send us Fan Mail Madeline Soto was a 13-year-old girl from Florida, whose disappearance in February 2024 sparked a desperate search and quickly became a case filled with…
- Episode 193: When the Predator is a Child: The Peter Woodcock Case · 1 h 35 minSend us Fan Mail In 1956, a shadow fell over Toronto when a quiet teenager named Peter Woodcock committed a series of unthinkable crimes, shattering the city's sense of safety…
- Episode 192: The Devil She Called Dad: The Harmony Montgomery Case · 1 h 35 min · Season 1 Episode 193Send us Fan Mail Harmony Montgomery was just 5 years old when she was murdered by her father, Adam Montgomery, in Manchester, New Hampshire, in December 2019. Despite multiple…
- Episode 191: The Anatomy of Obsession: The Laura Black Case · 1 h 41 minSend us Fan Mail In 1984, 22-year-old engineer Laura Black began working at ESL Inc. in Sunnyvale, California, where coworker Richard Farley quickly became obsessed with her…
- Episode 190: Hell Hath No Fury: The Betty Broderick Story · 1 h 21 min · Season 1 Episode 190Send us Fan Mail To the outside world, Betty Broderick had the perfect life. Living in an affluent San Diego suburb, she was the ultimate high-society housewife, mother to four…
- Episode 189: Murder for Fantasy-The Grant Amato Case · 1 h 38 min · Season 1 Episode 189Send us Fan Mail What begins as an online fantasy spirals into one of the most shocking family annihilation cases in recent memory. Grant Amato seemed to have everything going…
- Episode 188: The Long Drive: A Father's Deadly Secret — The Timothy Ray Jones Case · 56 min · Season 1 Episode 188Send us Fan Mail Timothy Ray Jones Jr. was a South Carolina father who murdered his five children—Merah (8), Elias (7), Nahtahn (6), Gabriel (2), and Abigail (1)—in August 2014…
- Episode 187: The Von Richthofen Family Murder · 1 h 24 min · Season 1 Episode 187Send us Fan Mail The Von Richthofen family murder was a notorious 2002 case in Brazil involving 18-year-old Suzane von Richthofen, who helped plan the murders of her wealthy…
- Episode 186: David Renz · 1 h 4 min · Season 1 Episode 186Send us Fan Mail In January 2013, David Renz was just another name on a federal docket, facing disturbing charges for the possession of child pornography. He was fitted with an…
- Episode 185: The Clarke Family · 1 h 34 min · Season 1 Episode 185Send us Fan Mail On February 19, 2020, an act of calculated violence in a quiet Brisbane suburb brought the reality of domestic abuse into the living rooms of every Australian…
- Episode 184: The Wesson Family // Part 2 · 1 h 40 min · Season 1 Episode 184Send us Fan Mail Marcus Wesson was a self-proclaimed religious leader whose twisted beliefs masked years of control, abuse, and unimaginable violence. In 2004, authorities in…
- Episode 183: The Wesson Family // Part 1 · 56 min · Season 1 Episode 183Send us Fan Mail Marcus Wesson was a self-proclaimed religious leader whose twisted beliefs masked years of control, abuse, and unimaginable violence. In 2004, authorities in…
- Episode 182: Russell Williams // Part 2 · 1 h 45 min · Season 1 Episode 182Send us Fan Mail In the quiet, upscale neighborhood of Tweed, Ontario, a shadow was moving through the darkness. For years, someone had been breaking into homes, stealing…
- Episode 181: Russell Williams // Part 1 · 1 h 24 min · Season 1 Episode 181Send us Fan Mail In the quiet, upscale neighborhood of Tweed, Ontario, a shadow was moving through the darkness. For years, someone had been breaking into homes, stealing…








