About this podcast
Hosted by Todd (in the Shadows) Nathanson and Alina Morgan, Song vs. Song pits two similar songs of an era against each other with controversial outcomes.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 204 episodes
- 178: "Season of the Witch" vs. "Witchy Woman" · 1 h 7 min · Episode 201SPOOKY SEASON! What's the most witchy song, or at least the witchiest song not by Stevie Nicks, definitive hippie Donovan's "Season of the Witch" or definitive non-hippies The…
- 177: "Peg" vs. "What a Fool Believes" (ft. Altamira!) · 1 h 3 min · Episode 200Song vs. Song enters the Michael McDonald-iverse! It's Yacht vs. Yacht as we take on two of the smoothest white-boy tracks of the '70s, but will the kings of snark Steely Dan win…
- BONUS EPISODE: Please put the VMAs out of its misery · 55 min · Episode 195The VMAs are now a zombie I.P. that only exists to give tribute to the old and dead, and has never felt more like an afterthought. See Privacy Policy at…
- 176: "Shut Up and Dance" vs. "Cake by the Ocean" (w/Molly Mary O'Brien!) · 1 h 11 min · Episode 194They were two of the biggest one-hit wonders of the mid-2010s, but do these vaguely throwback-y pop rock songs hold up, and which does it better? Pitchfork's Molly Mary O'Brien…
- 175: "White Rabbit" vs. "White Room" (w/Steven Hyden!) · 1 h 31 min · Episode 191We're back and we're taking a hit of the bad acid as we head back to the '60s and cover two towering hippie classics with suspiciously similar names! But which of the two tracks…
- Bonus Episode: The Muppets (2011) with Dan Olson! · 1 h 13 min · Episode 190While we are on break, a little taste of our bonus episodes on Patreon! And much thanks to Dan Olson for helping untangle the attempted, only partially successful Jim Henson…
- 174: "Hung Up" vs. "Can't Get You Out of My Head" (w/Jason Lipshutz!) · 1 h 15 min · Episode 186Two of the biggest international pop stars of the '80s and '90s ascended into world-conquering dance divas in the '00s, but which will shall reign supreme, Madonna's "Hung Up" or…
- 173: "Hungry Heart" vs. "Uptown Girl" · 1 h 3 min · Episode 185Two guys from the suburbs of NYC loved old doo-wop and '60s girl groups! Which bridge-and-tunnel legend's catchiest song is the better classic pop song, Bruce Springsteen's…
- 172: "Lovefool" vs. "Kiss Me" · 52 min · Episode 184Teen movies of the '90s needed a cute little twee song for teenagers to kiss to, but which was the most romantic of the two? Todd and Lina argue between "Kiss Me" by Sixpence…
- 171: "Dreams" vs. "You're So Vain" (w/Andrew Unterberger!) · 1 h 17 min · Episode 183Two of the finest and most devastating kiss-off tracks of the '70s, the songs that basically created the Main Pop Girl era five decades ahead of time, but which of these is the…
- 170: "Say So" vs. "Levitating" (w/AJ Marks!) · 1 h 30 min · Episode 182It's the pandemic and the dance floors are all closed but disco lives on! We invite Main Pod Girl's AJ Marks into the studio to help us debate which is the finest of the 2020…
- 169: "Shout" vs. "Relax" (w/Justin Lewis)! · 1 h 7 min · Episode 181It's the mid-'80s and two bands have figured out that what people want is British guys giving commands in two-note chanting choruses. Which is the best more-chorus-than-song song…
- 168: "Best of You" vs. "Like a Stone" (w/Pat Finnerty!) · 1 h 34 min · Episode 180If there's one thing we liked in rock in the 2000s, it was the '90s, and those who managed to survive it. But which band starring former members of grunge bands really made the…
- 167: "Breaking the Law" vs. "Ace of Spades" · 1 h 0 min · Episode 179What is the best metal song of 1980???? Is Lemmy God? Is he better than the Metal God Rob Halford? Is there a better song to wash your dog to??? Put on your studded metal because…
- 166: "Party Rock Anthem" vs. "Give Me Everything" (w/Mic the Snare) · 1 h 14 min · Episode 178Dale! Party rock is in the house tonight! The year is 2011 and nothing will ever feel bad ever again! But someone in the non-stop party has to be the party king so we're debating…
- 165: "Lay Lady Lay" vs. "Sweet Jane" (w/Spencer Breslin!) · 58 min · Episode 176Two of the greatest, mumbliest songwriters of the '60s decide to write sweet love songs! But only one can succeed between Dylan and Lou Reed, and we've brought star of "Disney's…
- BONUS EPISODE: "Wicked" (w/Sarah Z!) · 1 h 16 min · Episode 175To make up for a minor scheduling snafu, we are unlocking the vault and releasing one of our bonus episodes! We invite Wicked megafan Sarah Z into the studio to talk about the…
- 164: "Grace Kelly" vs. "I Don't Feel Like Dancin'" · 1 h 5 min · Episode 174Let us pick the best neo-glam rock song of the mid-00s! Who shall win, the faux-Queen belting of Mika's "Grace Kelly" or the Elton John-approved disco of the Scissor Sisters' "I…
- SPECIAL: The Grammys! Can they stay good?? (w/Mic the Snare!) · 1 h 10 min · Episode 1732026! Not as good as last year's Grammys, but what could be? So how did everyone do, and can this trend keep up? Also: Fuck ICE? See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy…
- 163: "Good Vibrations" vs. "A Day in the Life" · 1 h 4 min · Episode 172In the mid-1960s, two bands thought, what if rock and roll could be ART?? And so we got two masterpieces, but only one can stand as the greatest of all time, so who made the…







