Shownotes
In NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reviewed a preliminary injunction that blocked Mississippi from enforcing the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act against nine member platforms of the trade association NetChoice. The appellate court vacated the injunction, determining that NetChoice failed to provide the necessary platform- and function-specific factual evidence to support a valid as-applied First Amendment challenge. The court emphasized that in as-applied constitutional challenges involving complex new technologies, plaintiffs must establish with granular specificity how a law impinges upon protected conduct. Furthermore, the district court erred by issuing a blanket, overly broad remedy without conducting a rigorous, individualized analysis of how the statute uniquely burdens each covered company's distinct services. Consequently, the case was remanded for further proceedings requiring a more developed factual record and properly tailored injunctive relief.
Website: podcasters.spotify.com

