TAOI (these aren’t our ideas)
von Jake and Josh
Paul & Luke: The Problems Begin (Part 1)
Über diesen Podcast
These Aren’t Our Ideas is a podcast that questions inherited beliefs, challenges religious certainty, and explores where our ideas actually come from.
We dig into Christianity, the Bible, theology, philosophy, psychology, science, and history—pulling from biblical scholarship, ancient literature, Greek and Jewish worldviews, and modern thinkers. This isn’t about tearing things down for the sake of it. It’s about intellectual honesty, curiosity, and following the evidence wherever it leads.
Many of the ideas we carry feel personal, sacred, or unquestionable—but most of them were handed to us. In this podcast, we ask:
Who gave us these ideas? Why do we believe them? And what happens when we really examine them?
If you’ve ever felt tension between faith and reason, tradition and truth, belief and doubt—this space is for you.
Folgen
Die neuesten 20 von 28 Folgen
- Paul & Luke: The Problems Begin (Part 1) · 30 Min. · Folge 28In this episode, we examine Luke's opening claim that he has "carefully investigated everything" and set out to write an orderly and accurate account. But does the evidence…
- Is Christianity Just Paganism Repackaged? (Part 2) · 23 Min. · Folge 27What if Christianity had disappeared in the first century and was remembered today as just another ancient religious movement? Would its stories sound any different from the…
- Is Christianity Just Paganism Repackaged? (Part 1) · 28 Min. · Folge 26This episode examines whether Christian stories and rituals resemble older pagan myths, exploring shared themes like virgin births, dying-and-rising saviors, sacred meals, and…
- Worldviews Collide: Jesus Juice, Yahweh Energy and the Legend of Michael McFlur · 30 Min. · Folge 25A fast-paced episode that skewers online Christian personalities and products—from "Yahweh" energy drinks to ghost accounts and Michael McFlur memes—while debating creationist…
- Birthday Trip, Krishnamurti, & the Illusion of the Center · 20 Min. · Folge 24While on my birthday trip to the “city,” where Josh lives, we went to a massive bookstore. In this episode, we explore Krishnamurti’s radical ideas about being your own teacher…
- Junip: “In Every Direction” - Finding Your Center · 14 Min. · Folge 23In this bonus conversation, Jake and Josh discuss doubt, grief, and the music and books that led them to question external authorities structures like religion. They explore what…
- Rap, Reunion & Rebirth: A Candid Chat on Faith and Peace · 10 Min. · Folge 22Jake and Josh begin with playful banter about a surprise rap, reminiscing about DC Talk, Michael W. Smith, and concert memories while sharing family moments. The conversation…
- Belief: How Does it Play Out? (Part 5) · 30 Min. · Folge 21Belief, particularly Christian belief, looks very different depending on where you are, when you are, and who you’re talking to and being influenced by. What are we supposed to…
- Belief: Doubting Thomas (Part 4) · 31 Min. · Folge 20In this episode, Josh takes a spin at Belief. We look at belief through the lens of the apostles and the gospels. What was Doubting Thomas’s deal?
- Belief: Why Is “Correct Belief” Most Important (Part 3) · 20 Min. · Folge 19What if belief in concepts isn't simply "what the Bible teaches"? What if it's one interpretive model among many that can be built from the same collection of texts? In this…
- Belief: Fundamental Christianity - A Psychological and Philosophical Critique (Part 2) · 26 Min. · Folge 18For decades, these concepts have provided a powerful framework for understanding reality, God, human nature, suffering, salvation, and our ultimate destiny. But what happens when…
- Belief: Fundamentalism & the Jesus Movement (Part 1) · 18 Min. · Folge 17In this episode, we look at the deep fundamental baptist belief we were raised on, and how it came out of the cultural upheaval of the late 1960s and 1970s. As thousands of young…
- Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? Part 3: John's Cosmic Christ · 31 Min. · Folge 16Part 3 of our resurrection series turns to the final Gospel and perhaps the most theologically developed portrait of Jesus in the New Testament. By the time we reach John's…
- Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? Part 2: The Gospel Problem · 39 Min. · Folge 15Part 2 of our series on the resurrection moves from Paul—the earliest Christian writer—to the stories found in the Gospels themselves. What do Mark, Matthew, and Luke actually…
- Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? Part 1: Paul's Risen Christ · 37 Min. · Folge 14Before we ask whether Jesus rose from the dead, we have to ask a more basic question: What did the earliest Christians actually believe happened? In Part 1 of our three-part…
- A Random Conversation - Does God Explain Anything? · 26 Min. · Folge 13In this wide-ranging conversation, we explore some of humanity's oldest and most important questions. Does the universe require a creator, or can reality ultimately explain…
- Problems with Matthew (Part 2): Contradictions, Prophecy, and Historical Challenges · 49 Min. · Folge 12In Part 2 of Problems with Matthew, we explore some of the Gospel's most debated passages and claims. From apparent contradictions with other Gospel accounts to questions…
- Problems with Matthew (Part 1): Authorship, Sources, and Historical Questions · 43 Min. · Folge 11The Gospel of Matthew is often viewed as one of the most polished and influential books in the New Testament—but does that mean it's free from problems? In Part 1 of Problems…
- Problems with Mark (Part 2): Contradictions, the Missing Ending, and the Historical Questions · 42 Min. · Folge 10In Part 2 of Problems with Mark, we dig deeper into the Gospel's most challenging questions. We examine apparent contradictions, historical difficulties, the mysterious ending of…
- Problems with Mark (Part 1) · 34 Min. · Folge 9This is Part One of our series on the Gospel of Mark — and we’re going straight to the texts themselves. Why do Jews reject the Gospel of Mark? Not because they’re stubborn. Not…








