That's Disturbing - True Crime Podcast
by Gayle King - Host That's Disturbing
Episode 125: The Bell Witch: America's Most Terrifying Ghost Story
About this podcast
Conspiracy theories, real crime cases, and disturbing topics explored by Daphne and Gayle. From paranormal to murder, join us for chilling true crime stories.
That's Disturbing is entering a new chapter! After 121 episodes with Daphne and me, I'm now flying solo behind the microphone. Change can be a little strange, but it can also be exciting. I'm asking for honest opinions, not a roast session! There's absolutely nothing wrong with not liking the new format. Everyone has their preferences, and I completely respect that. For those of you sticking around, THANK YOU for your support.
Episodes
The newest 20 of 126 episodes
- Episode 125: The Bell Witch: America's Most Terrifying Ghost Story · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 125In 1817, a Tennessee farming family allegedly became the target of an invisible and increasingly violent presence. What began with scratching in the walls and mysterious knocks…
- The Last Trick-or-Treater A Chilling Halloween Horror Story · 27 min · Season 1 Episode 124In this special Halloween episode of That’s Disturbing , Gayle takes you into a chilling tale where an innocent Halloween tradition turns into something far more sinister. A…
- 123: Eastern State Penitentiary: The Prison Where the Dead Don't Rest · 23 minWhat happens when a prison built to save souls becomes one of America's most notorious haunted landmarks? This week on That's Disturbing, Gayle takes you inside Philadelphia's…
- 122: The Texas Cadet Murder Part 2: The Twisted Love Triangle That Killed Adrianne Jones · 27 minIn Part Two of The Texas Cadet Killings, we pick up where we left off in the tragic murder of 16-year-old Adrianne Jones. For months, Adrianne’s murder remained unsolved. Then…
- 121: A Conversation with Chris Papst About Failure Factory · 33 minThe real cost of a broken education system. Our interview with investigative journalist and author Chris Papst explores his powerful book. Failure Factory: How Baltimore City…
- 120: The Texas Cadet Murder Part 1: The Twisted Love Triangle That Killed Adrianne Jones · 40 minIn Part 1 of our deep dive into the infamous Texas Cadet Murder, we begin with the life and tragic death of 16 year old Adrianne Jones, whose 1995 murder in Texas would…
- 119: Dorothy Stratten: Playboy Playmate Murder, Obsession & a Hollywood Tragedy | True Crime · 35 minDorothy Stratten had everything Hollywood promised: beauty, fame, a Playboy Playmate of the Year title, and a career that seemed ready to explode. But behind the glamorous…
- 118: James Dean’s Little Bastard: The Cursed Car That Became a Hollywood Legend · 48 minIn this episode of That’s Disturbing, Daphne and Gayle are diving into James Dean’s infamous Porsche 550 Spyder, better known as Little Bastard, and the seriously creepy legend…
- 117: Behind The Boy With Wings: A Conversation with Mark Mustian · 40 minIn this episode of That’s Disturbing, Daphne and Gayle sit down with author Mark Mustian to talk about his novel The Boy With Wings. A story that blends history, memory, mystery…
- 116: “I Have You”: The Unsolved Murder of Dorothy Jane Scott · 43 minFor months, Dorothy Jane Scott received terrifying phone calls from an unidentified stalker who seemed to know her every move. Then, on May 28, 1980, Dorothy vanished from a…
- 115: The Great Dick and the Dysfunctional Demon: Interview with the Man Behind the Madness · 44 minIn this episode, we sit down with author Barry Maher to discuss his wildly original book, The Great Dick and the Dysfunctional Demon. We dive into the strange mysteries…
- 114: Black Sam Bellamy: The Robin Hood of the Sea | True Crime & Strange Mysteries · 48 minBlack Sam Bellamy wasn’t your average pirate. Known as the “Robin Hood of the Sea,” he was charming, stylish, surprisingly merciful, and also responsible for capturing more than…
- 113: The Bizarre Disappearances of Hannah Upp: The Woman Who Went Missing 3 Times · 34 minIn this episode of That's Disturbing, we're diving into one of the most baffling missing person cases we've ever covered: the story of Hannah Upp, a woman who disappeared under…
- 112: Creepy Stories of Haunted Paintings: Art That Stares Back · 36 minThis week, we’re stepping into the seriously unsettling world of haunted paintings apparently, even wall decor can have issues. Inspired by an episode of Supernatural, because of…
- 111: Black Dahlia Part 2: Suspects, Scandals & the Truth About Elizabeth Short · 1 h 29 minIn Part 2 of our Black Dahlia deep dive, we’re getting into the chaos after Elizabeth Short’s murder: the letters, the package of her belongings, the suspects, the theories, and…
- 110: The Sealed Secrets of Central Park: The Dark History of Ramble Cave · 51 minDeep inside Central Park’s winding, woodsy Ramble once hid a little cave with a big reputation and trust us, she was not just sitting there being cute and geological. Known as…
- 109: The Black Dahlia Murder Part 1: Elizabeth Short's Life, Death, and the Myths That Won't Die · 1 h 6 minThe Black Dahlia is one of the most infamous unsolved murders in American history, but how much of what you've heard is actually true? In Part 1 of our deep dive into the Black…
- 108: The Lead Masks Case: Brazil's Creepiest Unsolved Mystery · 25 minTwo men hike into the hills outside Rio de Janeiro carrying raincoats, cash, bottled water, and a journal. Days later, they're found dead. There are no signs of violence. No…
- 107: Rob Rosen Interview: Crimes of Omission OUT NOW · 1 h 14 minThis week on That's Disturbing, we're joined by award-winning investigative journalist, producer, and television creator Rob Rosen for a fascinating conversation that dives into…
- 106: The Most Famous Poltergeist Case in the World: Enfield Explained · 48 minThis week on That’s Disturbing, mother-daughter duo Gayle and Daphne dive into one of the most infamous paranormal cases in history: the Enfield Poltergeist. What started as…








