Zum Inhalt springen
Global sound
The Curious Task

The Curious Task

What's Wrong With The Notwithstanding Clause? - Leonid Sirota

· 1 Std. 8 Min. · Folge 329

Shownotes

In this episode, Alex speaks with constitutional scholar Leonid Sirota about the notwithstanding clause—what it does, how it functions within Canada’s constitutional architecture, and why its routine use undermines the very rights the Charter is meant to protect. Drawing on arguments from his National Post piece and earlier writing, Sirota explains why Section 33 was intended as an exceptional political safeguard, not a convenient escape hatch for governments, and why treating it as a routine tool erodes constitutionalism, weakens judicial oversight, and shifts the balance of power away from individuals and toward the state.
References
Leonid Sirota, “Yes, the notwithstanding clause overrides rights. No, it isn’t defensible.” — National Posthttps://nationalpost.com/opinion/leonid-sirota-yes-the-notwithstanding-clause-overrides-rights-no-it-isnt-defensible
“The Case Against the Notwithstanding Clause” — Leonid Sirota (Double Aspect)https://doubleaspect.blog/2018/10/04/the-case-against-the-notwithstanding-clause/
“Notwithstanding Myths” — Leonid Sirota (Double Aspect)https://doubleaspect.blog/2025/11/10/notwithstanding-myths/
Peter W. Hogg, Constitutional Law of Canada https://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/faculty_books/219/
The Constitution Act, 1982 (Section 33 — the Notwithstanding Clause)https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/rfc-dlc/ccrf-ccdl/check/art33.html
Thanks to Our Patrons
Including Kris Rondolo, Amy Willis, and Christopher McDonald. To support The Curious Task, visit: https://patreon.com/curioustask

Website: thecurioustask.podbean.com

Live, letzte Stunde: 13.091 Songs auf 6.568 Sendern in 140 Ländern

Entdecke die Welt über das Radio

Mehr zum Entdecken (9)

Etwas Schönes gehört? Speicher es oder öffne es direkt in Spotify.

★ Artist of the week The fastest riser on the radio this week
Your song here? From € 9 per week →
Radio DrachenblutWeiterhören