Shownotes
Drew Perkins welcomes math teacher and author Michael Pershan to explore the history of CLT and how he thinks about applying Cognitive Load Theory in his math teaching.
Links & Resources Mentioned In This Episode
Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected].
If you enjoyed this episode, please share it and please leave a review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you're listening.
Key Takeaways:
• Cognitive Load Theory as a Flexible Toolkit: Cognitive Load Theory is a context-dependent framework rather than a universal "silver bullet." Effective application requires adapting instruction to student proficiency—specifically accounting for the "Expertise Reversal Effect"—to ensure teaching methods remain calibrated to the learner's current stage.
• The Procedural-Conceptual Synthesis: Procedural fluency and conceptual understanding are not competing forces but complementary pillars of learning. Similar to how a baseball player refines their swing through technical coaching, students need both automaticity to handle complex tasks and explicit principles to assign meaning, with these skills developing concurrently.
• Prioritizing Classroom Reality over Academic Tribalism: Teachers need a pragmatic toolkit built for the "180-day reality" of the classroom, not just abstract pedagogical debates. Educators should be wary of over-applying narrow, isolated cognitive science findings to complex, holistic subjects and instead focus on whether research adequately maps the "whole territory" of daily instruction.
• Moving Beyond False Dichotomies: Debates such as "memory versus thinking" often create unhelpful academic divisions. In practice, these terms describe the same process from different angles; long-term memory is the repository of learning, and active, deep thinking is the necessary vehicle for building it.
Episode Highlights & Timecodes
• [00:07:34] Research Controversies: A candid discussion on the "You Cubed" project and the challenges of engaging in nuanced, critical dialogue with figures in the education field.
• [00:18:24] The Nature of Theory: Exploring why theories in human-centered sciences are more difficult to define and pin down than those in "hard" sciences.
• [00:23:15] From Critic to Proponent: How Michael moved from a skeptical stance on Cognitive Load Theory (CLT) to finding significant practical value in it through independent study and experimentation.
• [00:30:58] The Reality of School Culture: Why Michael is skeptical about teacher preparation programs, arguing that school culture often overrides academic training.
• [00:38:50] The "Political Coding" of Instruction: Examining why explicit instruction is increasingly viewed as "right-leaning" and why Michael critiques this tribalistic mentality as unhelpful.
• [00:43:35] The 180-Day Reality: An argument for a practical "theory of worksheets" that prioritizes daily classroom management over abstract debates.
• [00:47:47] The Expertise Reversal…
Website: wegrowteachers.com

