Time of Death
by Beth Braden
22. What the Witness Saw: The Blount County Trial Part 3
About this podcast
There are no witnesses, no fingerprints, and no confession to the 1992 deaths of Tommy Griffin and his sister, Connie Branam in East Tennessee.
There are, however, four alleged and un-investigated alternate suspects, six alibi witnesses, a disgraced medical examiner, a nearly impossible timeline, a bad search warrant, and a man named Gary Sutton sitting on Death Row. Did the state damn the wrong man to die?
Episodes
The newest 20 of 23 episodes
- 22. What the Witness Saw: The Blount County Trial Part 3 · 31 min · Season 1 Episode 22A court filing from last week included startling details about the man who attends Tennessee's executions, as well as declarations from attorneys who attended the two botched…
- 21. You Can't Be in Two Places At Once: Blount County Part 2 · 37 min · Season 1 Episode 21Time and trauma warps memories, and that leads to some shifting testimony between what some of the witnesses said in Blount County in 1996 versus what they said in Sevier County…
- 20. A Man With a Scar: The Blount County Trial Part 1 · 23 min · Season 1 Episode 20In some ways, the Blount County trial was identical to the first, right down to the order in which the state called its witnesses, but one of the waitresses from Howie's Hideaway…
- BONUS: The Christa Pike Tapes · 28 min · Season 1This week, Nashville, Tennessee's Department of Emergency Communications released a series of phone calls that routed through the DEC on the night of September 30, 2026 — the…
- 19. Gary Gets a Rare Win + Christa Pike Wakes Up · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 19Gary's formal reprieve was filed, and he has at least a year before the Tennessee Supreme Court can set a new execution date. Christa Pike has woken up after her botched…
- 18. BREAKING NEWS: A Botched Execution + Gary's Reprieve · 26 min · Season 1 Episode 18Things went terribly, terribly awry when the state of Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Gail Pike on September 30. It was so bad that Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee cancelled Gary…
- 17. Won't You Stay? Gary's Attorneys Ask for Pause on Execution · 35 min · Season 1 Episode 17Gary Wayne Sutton's attorneys have formally asked the Tennessee Supreme Court to stay his execution pending the outcome of his intellectual disability claim. Plus, Beth looks at…
- 16. One Headlight: The Sevier County Trial Part 3 · 45 min · Season 1 Episode 16Did the jury get lost in the weeds when testimony about Gary's headlights dealt a devastating blow to the defense's credibility? Also in this episode, the witnesses used to…
- 15. No Evidence: The Sevier County Trial Part 2 · 48 min · Season 1 Episode 15A man at Howie's Hideaway, and a woman who tracked Gary across Sevier County cause a huge problem with the state's timeline and theory regarding Connie Branam's death. PLUS - a…
- 14. I Didn't Say That: The Sevier County Trial Part 1 · 34 min · Season 1 Episode 14Changing stories and denials came out as Gary Sutton and James Dellinger's attorneys began cross examining witnesses during the 1993 Sevier County Trial for the death of Connie…
- 13. Pulled Rugs and Last Minute Revisions · 49 min · Season 1 Episode 13The past, present, and future collided for this episode as Anthony Darrell Hines execution came just days after the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that Gary Wayne…
- 12. (Alleged) Alt Suspects and Rabbit Holes Part 3 · 25 min · Season 1 Episode 12Bill Cogdill, the fourth and final alleged alternate suspect, had some pretty specific details about Connie Branam's crime scene several days before Connie was found burned in…
- 11. (Alleged) Alternate Suspects and Rabbit Holes Part 2 · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 11It turns out that not only were Connie Branam and Tommy Griffin supposed to be witnesses in a trial the week before their deaths…they were being subpoenaed as prosecution…
- 10. (Alleged) Alternate Suspects and Rabbit Holes - Part 1 · 55 min · Season 1 Episode 10Who are Bobby Floyd, Eddie Blair, Lester Johnson, and Bill Cogdill? Beth looks into the alternate suspects that, for whatever reason, were mostly ignored during Gary Sutton's…
- 9. The Race Was On · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 9• 🧑⚖️ Christa Pike asks Supreme Court to Halt Execution over abuse, illness • 📣 Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine calls to abolish death penalty in Ohio, victim's family reacts • ☕Buy Beth…
- 8. No Turning Back · 33 min · Season 1 Episode 8Connie Branam's car is found along Clear Fork above Wears Valley, and the cops conduct a search of James Dellinger's home. Then, Gary and James are arrested and charged with…
- 7. The Space Between · 41 min · Season 1 Episode 7Blount County Chief Detective Dale Gourley speaks to the media about Tommy Griffin's death and Connie Branam's disappearance as searchers comb Sevier County for the missing…
- 6. The Discovery · 42 min · Season 1 Episode 6The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals issued a stay in Gary Sutton's intellectual disability hearing, and Governor Bill Lee has granted Tony Caruthers a temporary reprieve from…
- 5. Another Saturday Night · 23 min · Season 1 Episode 5Connie Branam sat up nearly all night after her brother's trailer burned to the ground on February 21, 1992. On February 22, she began looking for him, and she ended up back at…
- 4. Diverging Timelines · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 4Alcoa, Tennessee, police officers find Tommy Griffin shirtless and beaten on the night of February 21, 1992, and arrest him for public intoxication. The state's theory of the…








