Truly Twisted
by Alecia Watson
Ep 68 | The Disappearance of Justin Rutter
About this podcast
Join me, your host Alecia Watson, every Thursday for a twisted and true story. This is a true crime podcast that shifts the focus where it belongs—on the victims. Through research and compassionate storytelling, I offer a respectful, fact-based perspective on true crime, ensuring that the victims are remembered not just for the crimes committed against them, but for the lives they lived and who they were all while immersing you in the mystery of what really happened.
Thank you so much for listening and remember that you are wanted, you are loved, and you deserve to be here.
Follow the show @ itstrulytwisted on Instagram and @trulytwisted on Tiktok.
Follow me personally @littleleesha
Subscribe over on Youtube https://www.youtube.com/@itstrulytwisted
Episodes
The newest 20 of 80 episodes
- Ep 68 | The Disappearance of Justin Rutter · 16 minOn October 8, 2009, 14-year-old Justin Rutter vanished after hanging out at a park in the Lowertown district of Ottawa, Ontario. What began as an ordinary evening turned into a…
- Bonus | Podcasting, Movies, and More with Steven Ray Morris · 1 h 1 minThis week as a special bonus we have my discussion with Steven Ray Morris about our careers in podcasting, our friends in the industry, horror movies, Halloween and more. Steven…
- Horror House: True Crime and the Macabre | The Great Maple Syrup Heist · 46 min*** Hey Twisted Family. As some of you know, I have been grieving the loss of our fury producer and the littlest love of my life, my rabbit Thumper. He died two weeks ago and I…
- Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast | A Reddit Horror Anthology · 1 h 38 minAs a Halloween bonus to my twisted family, I wanted to share this very special anthology I was a part of for Perplexity A Mystery Podcast celebrating 200 episodes. Enjoy a creepy…
- Ep 67 | The LaLaurie Mansion · 48 minThere are some houses that seem to hold onto their history. And then there are houses where the history is so dark, so disturbing, that people have spent nearly two centuries…
- Ep 66 | The Villisca Axe House · 43 minOn June 9th 1912 the Moore family went to bed at their home in Villisca Iowa along with their two guests. It was a seemingly peaceful summer night. Villisca was described as…
- Ep 65 | The SK Pierce Mansion · 32 minThe S.K. Pierce Mansion is a towering Second Empire Victorian home in Gardner, Massachusetts, built between 1873 and 1875. From the outside, it looks almost exactly like the kind…
- Ep 64 | The Amityville Horror House · 23 minFor our next haunted house with a true crime origin we are heading to Amityville in Long Island New York. This week Alecia is joined by a special guest, Sierra Zorn, on the mic…
- Ep 63 | The Lizzie Borden House · 27 minOn August 4th, 1892, 69-year-old Andrew Borden settled onto his living room couch for a mid-morning nap at 11 AM, but he would never wake up. Instead, he would be gruesomely…
- Ep 62 | The Unsolved Murder of Tracy Cusick · 17 minIn January of 2006, 32-year-old mother of two Tracy Cusick was found dead in her Illinois home, submerged face-down in her bathroom toilet. Her death was initially ruled a tragic…
- Ep 61 | The Disappearance of Max Devries · 18 minThere are certain names that are well known because of vacation tragedies—Madeline McCain, Amy Lynn Bradley and Natalee Holloway. Their stories have been told around the world…
- Ep 60 | The Murders of Kaylee, Madison, Xana, and Ethan Part 2 · 27 minWhen we left in Part 1, we had come full circle from the events of November 12th and 13th 2022 by Kaylee, Maddie, Xana, and Ethan leading up to the 911 call bringing police to…
- Ep 60 | The Murders of Kaylee, Madison, Xana, and Ethan Part 1 · 16 minIn the early morning hours of November 13th 2022 four University of Idaho students were brutally murdered in the home they shared. For months the community was left feeling…
- From The Vault | The Murders of Libby German and Abby Williams · 23 min***Hey Twisted Family, I am so sorry, I am still very sick, but I couldnt leave you without a story. Here is a case from my personal vault originally recorded in October of 2025…
- From The Vault | The Unsolved Murder of Lindsay Buziak · 29 min***Hey Twisted Family, I am so sorry, I have been so sick lately and was not able to get Episode 60 recorded but I promise you it is worth the wait. Here is a recorded story from…
- Ep 59 | The Disappearance of Tiffany Daniels · 14 minOn August 20th, 2013 Tiffany Daniels’ 1999 Toyota Forerunner was found abandoned in a public parking lot at Pensacola Beach West. Her phone, wallet, and personal belongings were…
- Ep 58 | The Unsolved Murder of Crystal Marler · 11 minOn October 8th 1998, 15 year old Crystal Marler was dropped off at a friend's house in Whitley City Kentucky and was never heard from again. For 11 years, Crystal's disappearance…
- Ep 57 | The Disappearance of Marshal Iwaasa · 16 minOn the morning of November 18th, 2019, 26 year old Marshal Iwaasa left a storage unit that he rented in Lethbridge Alberta after spending around two hours there. Then, five days…
- Ep 56 | The Murders of Shawndell Mcleod and Rosalyn Lewis · 18 min35 year-old Shawndell Mcleod woke up early in the morning on September 25th 2011 to start her shift opening the kitchen at the nursing home near her home in Lithonia Georgia. She…
- Ep 55 | The Murders of Rachel Nickell and Samantha and Jazmine Bisset · 19 minOn the morning of July 15th, 1992, 23 year old Rachel Nickell was walking with her young son and dog in Wimbledon Common in Southeast London. It was broad daylight and she would…







