Confessions of a Reluctant Caregiver
by Natalie Elliott Handy and JJ Elliott Hill
2025 – The Plot Twist That’s Changing Everything
About this podcast
The Confessions of a Reluctant Caregiver podcast offers a candid, unfiltered space to confess the good, the bad, and the ugly of being a caregiver through storytelling, guest interviews, and information sharing. JJ & Natalie are a dynamic duo of sisters supporting their mom living with Parkinson's and a husband who survived cancer. Along with their guests, they discuss their shared experiences in caregiving. Viewers and listeners alike will relate to our reluctance, be affirmed in their ability to be caregivers and gain the courage to confidently step out of the shadows to express their own needs. You are sure to laugh, cry, and everything in between but in the end, all will leave feeling better for the journey and part of the sisterhood of care. So grab your favorite guilty pleasure, and let's get to confessing!
Episodes
The newest 20 of 206 episodes
- 2025 – The Plot Twist That’s Changing Everything · 44 min · Episode 1532025 brought twists, wins, and one announcement that changes everything. The sisters drop the news, spill the truth, and ask every listener to jump in for what’s next. Social…
- Caregiver Groundhog Day: Lessons We Keep Learning · 1 h 0 min · Episode 111If caregiving feels like the same day on repeat, you’re not alone. The sisters laugh, vent, and reflect on the patterns that just keep showing up. Support the show Confessions of…
- Wait… Haven’t We Been Here Before? · 56 min · Episode 151Some stories are worth a second listen. The sisters rewind time to reflect, laugh, and prove that caregiving chaos never gets old. Support the show Confessions of a Reluctant…
- The Lost Episode: Looking Back with the Original Reluctant Caregivers · 52 min · Episode 150In August 2023, Confessions of a Reluctant Caregiver took an exciting leap across the pond — airing on UK Health Radio and sharing caregiver stories with an international…
- Competing Priorities: Balancing Family, Career and Caregiving · 52 min · Episode 149In this episode, Ed DeVaney joins the sisters of "Confessions of a Reluctant Caregiver" to share his deeply personal caregiving experience. Raised in a competitive and close-knit…
- Dad, Devotion, and Dancing: Finding Joy in the Hardest Goodbye · 1 h 1 min · Episode 148This week’s episode focuses on Christopher “Chris” Schuler—his journey as a son, father, and most notably, a devoted caregiver. Chris, adopted from Colombia and raised in a…
- Not Stuck in the Yuck: Tricia’s Story of Family, Advocacy, and Strength · 57 min · Episode 147Tricia Fitzgerald brings a deeply personal and candid perspective to the experiences of long-term caregiving within a family affected by chronic illness. Drawing from over two…
- Disrupting Care: How Neal Shah Is Revolutionizing Support for Families · 1 h 8 min · Episode 146Neal Shah’s journey, showcases the impact of caregiving on individual lives and the broader healthcare system. Raised in a close-knit immigrant family, Neal's values were shaped…
- When Life Calls: Zack’s Story of Stepping Up for Family and Changing the Caregiving Conversation · 1 h 3 min · Episode 145Zack Demopoulos’s story begins with his upbringing as the proud son of Greek immigrants, whose journey to the United States instilled in him a deep sense of gratitude…
- Compassion in Action: Donna’s Path from Caregiver to Changemaker · 1 h 0 min · Episode 144With a lifelong passion for nursing, Donna Steigleder’s journey began in her childhood and evolved into a career in healthcare, where she gained a wealth of experience across…
- The Power of the Pause: Finding Relief in Caregiving with Jenn Fredericks · 56 min · Episode 143Jenn Fredericks is the featured guest in this episode, sharing her deeply personal journey as both a long-term patient and a dedicated caregiver. Diagnosed with chronic kidney…
- The Power of Three and Twelve: Jason’s Caregiving Blueprint · 59 min · Episode 142Jason Binder, the founder of Aware Coaching, is a dedicated husband and father of five. His caregiving journey began unexpectedly when his wife, Tracy, a lively marathon runner…
- Boundaries, Faith, and Family: Lessons from Jenifer Massie’s Caregiving Journey · 1 h 0 min · Episode 141From a young age, Jenifer Massie was immersed in a culture of service, beginning with volunteering in her school’s “gramps and grannies” program and extending to caring for her…
- Surviving the Grief Buffet: Angela’s Journey Through Caregiving and Loss · 1 h 6 min · Episode 140Over the course of several years, Angela Ibarra faced a series of profound losses, including her husband, her mother, her job, and eventually her father. Her caregiving journey…
- Did Mom Drop Acid? Navigating Dementia and Family Dynamics · 58 min · Episode 139Michelle Cain’s journey as a caregiver began when her mother was diagnosed with Lewy Body dementia during the pandemic, a time already fraught with uncertainty and stress. At 47…
- The Power of Family: Navigating ALS Across Generations · 57 min · Episode 138The story of Mollie and Maureen powerfully illustrates the emotional depth and complexities of family caregiving when ALS profoundly impacts a household. Maureen, a pediatric…
- Confessions of a Young Widow: Rising Above Grief · 58 min · Episode 137Shannon Traphagen became a caregiver at 43 when her husband Mike was diagnosed with incurable brain cancer. Their 14-month battle was fraught with heartbreak, including losing an…
- Not What We Signed Up For: Embracing an Unexpected Path · 1 h 1 min · Episode 136When Rachel Shapiro’s daughter suffered a severe stroke just before her second birthday, Rachel and her husband were told their child might not survive. Despite the devastating…
- Surviving, Thriving, and Loving Again · 1 h 0 min · Episode 135Stacy Ryan’s powerful story is a testament to love, resilience, and the human capacity to heal after profound loss. Her journey began with her own cancer diagnosis at 45, which…
- Love Creatively: A Caregiver's Colorful Journey · 59 min · Episode 134This week, Ari Medrano delivers a powerful testament to the depth and complexity of caregiving. As a Mexican immigrant who came to the United States at age one, Ari's approach to…








