Gary's Scaries
by DAMN
Latest episode
Gary's Scaries, Episode 15 - Ghost Cats (Live from Gary's Basement!)
Gary's Scaries, Episode 15 - Ghost Cats (Live from Gary's Basement!)
About this podcast
Caitlyn reads spine-chilling true paranormal stories to her co-host Gary - who hates scary stuff. Gary listens (sometimes reluctantly), then rates just how terrifying each tale really is. Expect an hour of hair-raising tales overtop nervous laughter as they explore the creepy, the weird, and the unexplained
Episodes
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 15 - Ghost Cats (Live from Gary's Basement!) · 1 h 9 min · Episode 15In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn and Gary go live from Gary's basement, and return to reading local ghost stories. Streamed live on October 30th 2026. ~GARY'S…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 14 - The Haunted Campus Tour w/ Murray Gross · 33 min · Episode 14In this very special episode of Gary's Scaries, our guest Murray Gross gives Caitlyn and Gary a tour of the spookiest places on the U of S campus. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn reads…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 13 - Conspiracies · 1 h 14 min · Episode 13In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn and Gary read each other their favorite conspiracy theories. Streamed live on September 18th 2026. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn reads…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 12 - The Appalachian Mountains · 1 h 6 min · Episode 12In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn reads the scariest stories from the Appalachian Mountains, and Gary reacts. Streamed live on August 21st 2026. ~GARY'S SCARIES~…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 11 - EVPs · 1 h 2 min · Episode 11In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn reads the scariest EVP stories, and Gary reacts. Streamed live on June 26th 2026. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn reads spine-chilling true…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 10 - Night Shifts · 1 h 9 min · Episode 10In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn reads the scariest stories from night shift workers, and Gary reacts. Streamed live on May 29th 2026. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn reads…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 9 - Ouija Boards · 1 h 1 min · Episode 9In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn reads the scariest Ouija Board stories, and Gary reacts. Streamed live on April 17th 2026. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn reads…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 8 - Kids · 1 h 5 min · Episode 8In this episode of Gary's Scaries, Caitlyn reads the scariest stories of children encountering the paranormal, and Gary reacts. Streamed live on February 20th 2026. ~GARY'S…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 7 - First Responders · 1 h 3 min · Episode 7In our first themed episode, Caitlyn reads the scariest stories from first responders, and Gary reacts. Streamed live on January 23rd 2026. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn reads…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 6 - Cold Spots · 1 h 6 min · Episode 6Includes stories of a disappearing old man, doll heads turning on their own, and an unnaturally cold basement. Streamed live on November 21st 2025. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 5 - Faces · 1 h 3 min · Episode 5Includes stories of a roommate being blamed for poltergeist activity, mirrors pointing at each other, and a long account of a childhood in the basement of a haunted house…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 4 - Stairs · 1 h 5 min · Episode 4Includes stories of a local band with questionable tour accommodations, money flying out of a tip jar, and childhood memories of hooded spirits walking through a home. Streamed…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 3 - Portals · 1 h 2 min · Episode 3Includes stories of laughter in an abandoned building, ghost trains, and the many spirits inside local hospitals. Streamed live on October 27th 2025. ~GARY'S SCARIES~ Caitlyn…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 2 - Ducklings · 1 h 9 min · Episode 2Includes stories of an aunt who's family whispered was a witch, and a young couple who is seemingly followed by a destructive presence. Streamed live on September 26th 2025…
- Gary's Scaries, Episode 1 - Knives · 1 h 7 min · Episode 1Includes stories of four men moving into a haunted rental home, a girl hearing footsteps coming up the stairs every night after everyone else is asleep, and an urban legend of a…







