Wait, Explain That?
by Heather and Natalie
Sandra Birchmore: Farwell Found Guilty. Now Who Answers for the…
About this podcast
The story everyone knows is where we start. The question nobody asked is where we go.
Welcome to Wait, Explain That? — the podcast for people who hear a story and immediately have 47 follow-up questions.
Best friends Heather and Natalie dive into true crime, unsolved mysteries, bizarre history, cults, scams, psychology, espionage, and real-life stories so unbelievable they sound made up.
We go beyond the headlines, digging through court records, police reports, original documents, and overlooked details to uncover what happened, what doesn’t add up, and what everyone else seems to have moved past.
Expect deep research, skeptical questions, unexpected twists, dark humor, and the occasional rabbit hole we probably should have left alone.
Because the story is never just the story.
🎙️ New episodes every Tuesday.
Episodes
- Sandra Birchmore: Farwell Found Guilty. Now Who Answers for the Rest? | Episode 9 Update · 15 min · Season 1Matthew Farwell has been convicted of murdering Sandra Birchmore and causing the death of her unborn child. But apparently, the guilty verdict isn't the end of this story. Just…
- Sandra Birchmore: A Deadly Abuse of Power | Episode 9 · 54 min · Season 1 Episode 9Sandra Birchmore was just 15 years old when she became involved with the Stoughton Police Explorers program in Massachusetts. It was supposed to be an opportunity to learn about…
- Lauren Ashley Patterson: Her Final Moments Were on His Phone · 24 min · Season 1 Episode 8Lauren Ashley Patterson: Her Final Moments Were on Her Phone | Episode 8 On October 4, 2026, a 17-year-old boy called 911 from a home in Kirtland, New Mexico. His mother, Lauren…
- Sonia Exelby: The $4,000 Deal and the Messages That Changed Everything | Episode 7 · 48 min · Season 1 Episode 7She traveled from England to Florida to meet a man she'd been talking to online for nearly two years. Investigators say their arrangement involved torture, money, and her death…
- Christa Pike: The Murder of Colleen Slemmer | Death, Life & Probation · 45 min · Season 1 Episode 6She was 19 years old. Her killer became infamous. But somewhere along the way, the world stopped talking about Colleen Slemmer. In January 1995, Colleen Slemmer was lured into…
- Miranda Corsette: Everyone Knew Something · 32 min · Season 1 Episode 5Sixteen-year-old Miranda Corsette was murdered in St. Petersburg, Florida, in February 2025. Steven Gress and Michelle Brandes are accused of her brutal captivity, torture, and…
- The Florida Keys Murders: Satanic Panic, Unsolved Cases & Charlie Brandt · 42 min · Season 1 Episode 4A murdered 4-year-old. A young woman killed after leaving a party. Another woman whose murder would later be linked to a suspected serial killer. And a community gripped by…
- How to Fake Your Own Death · 31 min · Season 1 Episode 3What if you wanted to disappear completely... and collect your own life insurance money while you were still alive? In the late 1980s, Gene Hanson and John Hawkins had built a…
- The Couple With Two Names — Part 2 · 18 min · Season 1 Episode 2The fake identities are blown. The parents are in custody. And somehow, their own children still don’t know who they really are. In Part 2, Heather and Natalie follow the…
- The Couple With Two Names — Part 1 · 27 min · Season 1 Episode 1They were already married. Then they met again as strangers. Different names. Different histories. A second wedding. Two children growing up inside a life that looked completely…








