Dogmalysis
by Dr Richard Haydon
More CPR, Same Survival? RACE-CARS and the Responder App Chain
About this podcast
Dogmalysis (Dogma-lysis) tests common emergency medicine beliefs against the evidence. Presented by Rigel the Podcast Bot in association with Dr Richard Haydon, Emergency Physician, Melbourne, Australia. Teaching content only, not clinical advice. No patient data.
Episodes
- More CPR, Same Survival? RACE-CARS and the Responder App Chain · 10 min · Episode 20Train the public and alert volunteers, and will bystander CPR and survival follow? RACE-CARS (NEJM 2026; North Carolina cluster RCT, 22,459 patients; a dispatch…
- Racing the Clock to Flow: ON-SCENE and Prehospital ECPR · 11 min · Episode 19Did INCEPTION (2023; 30-day good neurological survival 20% vs 16%, 74 min to flow) prove ECPR doesn't work, or that a slow system doesn't? ON-SCENE (NEJM 2026; nationwide Dutch…
- Steroids Are Not a Force Field: Switching Contrast After a Reaction · 9 min · Episode 18After a prior iodinated contrast reaction, is it the steroid or the switch that prevents a repeat? The steroid RCTs (Lasser 1987/1994) were in unselected patients, mostly ionic…
- The Clock Isn't the Airway: Fasting, Mallampati and ASA in ED Sedation · 10 min · Episode 17ACEP 2026: urgent and emergent procedures "should not be delayed solely based upon fasting times"; Mallampati "should not be required"; ASA should be de-emphasised. Beach 2016…
- Every Six Seconds, Says Who? The CPR Ventilation Numbers · 10 min · Episode 16Are 30:2, 10 breaths/min and 400–600 mL evidence-based? ILCOR 2005 wrote "insufficient evidence" for any ratio and chose 30:2 to simplify teaching. The 10/min warning traces to…
- The Tube Isn't the Bottleneck: PRESC1SE-MI and the One-Hour Troponin · 11 min · Episode 15PRESC1SE-MI (Lancet 2026; stepped-wedge cluster RCT, 19 hospitals in 10 countries, 67,624 presentations) switched central-lab hs-troponin pathways from 0/3 h to 0/1 h. Second…
- Acute Pain Is Not the Long Tail: Steroids in Shingles · 10 min · Episode 14Wood NEJM 1994 (n=400): acute pain better at d7/d14 (P
- The Scanner Isn't the Test: Clearing the Paediatric C-Spine on CT · 9 min · Episode 13Russell et al. (J Trauma Acute Care Surg 2026; 72 US centres; 12,693 children with C-spine CT after blunt trauma). For surgery/halo-defined injury (n=150, 1.2%): as-read…
- Finding a Rhythm Isn't Fewer Faints: ASPIRED and the 14-Day Patch · 9 min · Episode 12ASPIRED (Reed et al., NEJM 2026; 2,234 adults, 45 UK EDs) randomised unexplained ED syncope to an immediate 14-day patch or usual care. Syncope episodes at 1 y: IRR 0.89…
- Faster Isn't the Same as Safe: Bedside Troponin and ICare-FASTER · 9 min · Episode 10Swapping the lab hs-troponin I for a bedside version, with the same pathway, cut ED stays across six NZ departments: 30 minutes excluding the non-randomised site, 47 minutes…
- The Map Is Not the Territory: CO2, the Strong Ion Difference and the Apnoea Test · 12 min · Episode 11Stewart's model treats CO2 and the strong ion difference as independent. A BJA study of 263 apnoea tests shows acute hypercapnia raises SID by about 1.2–1.5 mmol/L per 0.1 fall…
- Never Proven? Anticoagulation for Clots, from PRAGUE to Barritt · 15 min · Episode 9PRAGUE-26 tests catheter-directed alteplase on top of anticoagulation, and most of its benefit is in soft, unblinded decompensation outcomes. But does the anticoagulation itself…
- Never proven interchangeable (intermittent haemodialysis vs CRRT after ICRAKI) · 9 min · Episode 8For years, null trials of intermittent haemodialysis versus CRRT were read as proof the two are interchangeable. ICRAKI, a French trial in ventilated or shocked patients with…
- Not small adults (can we safely rule out PE in children?) · 9 min · Episode 7'Paediatric PE is too rare to need a rule' uses the wrong base rate: about 6% of children who are worked up for it have it. BEEPER, a prospective study of nearly 4,000 children…
- The second pressor (does starting vasopressin early save lives in septic shock?) · 9 min · Episode 6Many of us were taught to add vasopressin early, at a low noradrenaline dose, to spare catecholamines and save kidneys. VASSPR, a trial of nearly 4,000 patients in JAMA this…
- Accurate isn't useful (AI in the ED) · 8 min · Episode 5Why an accurate AI tool isn't automatically a useful one in the emergency department. Teaching content only, not clinical advice.
- Stop fussing about the middle (post-ROSC oxygen and temperature) · 8 min · Episode 4Oxygen and temperature targets after ROSC: what the trials actually show. Teaching content only, not clinical advice.
- Treating the number (bicarbonate in arrest and shock) · 9 min · Episode 3Does bicarbonate help in cardiac arrest and shock, or are we treating a number? Teaching content only, not clinical advice.
- The first litre (fluids first vs early pressors in septic shock) · 8 min · Episode 2Fluids first or early vasopressors in septic shock? We test the dogma against the evidence. Teaching content only, not clinical advice.
- A bag of mag (magnesium in rapid AF) · 10 min · Episode 1Does a bag of mag belong in rapid AF? Right drug, wrong expectation. We turn the belief dial through Davey & Teubner 2005, Ho 2007, LOMAGHI, Chu 2009 and MAGMAR. Take-home: rate…








